For centuries, the free market has set the wages for most jobs. Supply and demand are far better at determining the optimal wage than the government. But free enterprise has its enemies. While most people would like a salary increase, some actually expect the government to require one.
Several decades ago the theory of "comparable worth" emerged for government oversight of wages. Its proponents insisted that businesses must pay the same wages to women in predominantly female occupations as are paid to men in "comparable" occupations that are predominantly male.
Congress has consistently rejected attempts to enact comparable worth. So its promoters have turned to activist judges, and are racking up victories.
Emporia State University in Kansas is the latest victim. Maxine Mehus earned $46,499 as its women’s volleyball coach, but she felt she deserved more and also sought release from her teaching responsibilities.
She complained that the men who coached football and basketball made $14,000 to $17,000 more than she did, and they did not have to teach. She sued for alleged violation of the Equal Pay Act and Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
Her good fortune landed her in the courtroom of Judge Kathryn H. Vratil. Appointed by the first President Bush, she once allowed minority passen-gers to go to trial against Southwest Airlines based on a charge of racism against a stewardess for announcing, "Eenie, meenie, minie, moe; pick a seat, we gotta go!" A 48-year-old plaintiff claimed "it was like I was too dumb to find a seat," and noted that the nursery rhyme has an old racist version.
Congress expressly limited application of the Equal Pay Act to situations involving "equal work on jobs the performance of which requires equal skill, effort, and responsibility, and which are performed under similar working conditions." 29 U.S.C. § 206(d)(1). The regulations emphasize that the relevant jobs be "substantially equal" in order for the Equal Pay Act to apply. 29 C.F.R. § 1620.13(a). Â
But viewed from the courtroom of Judge Vratil, coaching volleyball is "substantially equal" to coaching football or basketball. Mehus v. Emporia State Univ., 222 F.R.D. 455 (D. Kan. June 30, 2004). The football team had 28,497 paid attendees in a recent season compared to zero for the volleyball team, and football is a dangerous sport while volleyball is not, but the judge held that the coaching jobs are roughly the same.
Judge Vratil decided that plaintiff Mehus can have a jury trial in the hope of winning a huge award, plus attorney’s fees. Her claim of sex discrimination under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act was also allowed.Â
This decision comes on the heels of a ruling by a San Francisco judge that Wal-Mart may be liable for billions of dollars because it paid women employ-ees at various levels less than male supervisors. Dukes v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., 222 F.R.D. 137 (N.D. Ca. June 21, 2004). Courts have made clear that they will interfere with the free market, unless and until Congress removes their jurisdiction over comparing wages paid for different jobs.