Court Monitor • Nov 13, 2004

Affirmative Action for Liberal Speech?

Text Reader

Roderick Jackson has been a tenured physical education teacher at Ensley public high school. He also coached the girls’ basketball team, until the Birmingham Board of Education decided to replace him without affecting his teaching position.  Coach Jackson sued for being replaced. He alleged that his complaints about unequal funding of the girls’ team compared to the boys’ caused his firing. Title IX prohibits discrimination against an athlete based on gender. But Coach Jackson is male and did not personally suffer any discrimination for being a man. Instead, he insists that he can sue for alleged retaliation. This case presents a new way to erode employers’ rights to hire and fire without court interference. The traditional rule, "employment at will," is that what the boss says, goes.  Mr. Jackson did not lose his teaching job at the school, yet seeks an entitlement to continue coaching a particular sports team. His case went before the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals, which presides over Alabama, Georgia and Florida. "The question before us is whether Title IX implies a private right of action in favor of individuals who, although not themselves the victims of gender discrimination, suffer retaliation because they have complained about gender discrimination suffered by others." Jackson v. Birmingham Bd. of Ed., 309 F.3d 1333 (11th Cir. 2002). Mr. Jackson argued his appeal pro se, without the benefit of an attorney. The appellate court ruled against him unanimously. The court held that someone cannot sue over gender discrimination allegedly suffered by other people. Only the direct victims may sue, and as a man Mr. Jackson could not claim that he was the victim of gender discrimination. The appellate court became the first to apply the landmark ruling of Alexander v. Sandoval to claims of gender discrimination. 532 U.S. 275 (2001) That decision closed the door to lawsuits for alleged discrimination that had not been expressly authorized by Congress. End of the story? Enter the National Women’s Law Center, which pushes quota-like goals by gender in school programs. It appealed this decision to the U.S. Supreme Court and found help among the Bush Administration attorneys.    The Supreme Court asked Bush’s Solicitor General’s office for its opinion, and it delivered the legal equivalent of a home run for those alleging discrimination. The Bush Administration declared that coaches should be able to sue for retaliation if based on complaints about gender equality. This would open up a whole new vista of litigation and job protection for disgruntled liberals. As urged by the Bush Administration attorneys, the Supreme Court will consider this issue in the fall. And because Title IX applies to all education programs and activities receiving federal financial assistance, this dispute extends beyond the playing fields into the classrooms. Until now, actions for discrimination have been limited to allegations of direct injury by a member of a disadvantaged group. Will the Supreme Court now allow discrimination lawsuits based merely on what someone said rather than who he is? Federal judges could soon be spending more time reviewing high school personnel decisions.