The practice of judges simply parroting the views of one side has long plagued the court system. Many a misguided opinion has resulted from over-reliance by a judge on arguments presented by a liberal advocate. The Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit just issued a remarkable decision to stop this practice. It reversed a judgment by a lower court with this simple command to the trial judge: Do your own work! Â
The tragic facts were familiar. While Charles Koschalk was free on probation after pleading guilty to corrupting the morals of a girl, he murdered the girl’s sister. The victims’ father, John Bright, justifiably outraged, sued the probation officer, the probation supervisor, the local town, the police officer, the county court and the district attorney. At the status conference on September 17, 2003, federal Judge Schwab had a surprise for Mr. Bright: the judge announced that he planned to dismiss the lawsuit. Adding insult to injury, the judge said his decision was based on a prior unpublished opinion of his district court. At that point, Bright had not even submitted his legal brief. The judge had apparently made up his mind based entirely on the submission by the town officials.
Judge Schwab next requested the defendants to submit their statement of position rather than replying to the anticipated brief by Bright. For his opinion and order dismissing Bright’s lawsuit, Judge Schwab copied nearly verbatim from defendants’ statement of position.
Bright appealed. Because this type of copying by judges is pervasive, Mr. Bright’s attorney devoted only one footnote in his entire appellate brief to complain about it. Yet that footnote won the case on appeal. Bright v. Westmoreland County, 380 F.3d 729 (3d Cir. Aug. 24, 2004). "When a court adopts a party’s proposed opinion as its own, the court vitiates the vital purposes served by judicial opinions. We, therefore, cannot condone the practice used by the District Court in this case." The Third Circuit quoted a 1961 decision by the Fourth Circuit that had issued the same warning: "there is no authority in the federal courts that countenances the preparation of the opinion by the attorney for either side. That practice involves the failure of the trial judge to perform his judicial function." Chicopee Mfg. Corp. v. Kendall Co., 288 F.2d 719, 725 (4th Cir. 1961).
As Judge Nygaard observed in siding with Bright, the reason that courts and judges exist is "to provide neutral fora in which persons and entities can have their professional disputes and personal crises resolved."Â Any departure from that standard calls into question the "legitimacy and effectiveness" of the judiciary. He could have added that taxpayers are not getting their money’s worth when judges fail to do what they are paid to do.
Is this ruling another step towards restoring discipline to our legal system?