God was banned long ago from the classroom, but Christians have not given up. "Good News" clubs have arisen in many public schools to give students an opportunity to share their faith. Â
Aggressive lawsuits attempted to ban these clubs from public schools, even when they convened after hours. But the U.S. Supreme Court, in an opinion written by Justice Thomas, finally gave religious groups after-school access to public schools on an equal footing with other clubs. Good News Club v. Milford Central School, 533 U.S. 98 (2001). Yet the war is far from over. The latest battle was fought in Sioux Falls, South Dakota, home state of the defeated Senate Democratic Party leader Tom Daschle.
Barbara Wigg taught second and third grade in the Sioux Falls School District. Generously donating time to help children, she typically arrived before the school day began at 7:30 a.m., and stayed long afterwards to help with the Girl Scouts and give private guitar and reading lessons.
On December 15, 2002, she attended the first meeting of the Good News Club at her elementary school. She met in the school library with nine students, with their parents’ approval, after conclusion of the day’s classes.
Ms. Wigg played a game with the students, who also learned a Bible verse and listened to a Christian story. School district policy expressly allows these clubs to meet on school property, in compliance with the Supreme Court decision mentioned above.
But a staff employee of the school immediately complained about Ms. Wigg’s participation in the Club. The staffer went to the principal to insist that Ms. Wigg be banned from teaching religion on public school property. The principal agreed and ordered Ms. Wigg not to participate in any more Good News Club meetings. She appealed to the superintendent, to no avail.
Ms. Wigg sued for the right to attend these meetings. The district judge, however, held that she would only be able to go to Good News meetings at other schools, not at the one where she teaches.    Â
She appealed to the Eighth Circuit and, nearly two years later, won a total victory. Wigg v. Sioux Falls School District 49-5, 382 F.3d 807 (8th Cir. Sept. 3, 2004). The Court held that she had a right to attend Good News Clubs at her own school.
"The guarantee of neutrality is respected, not offended, when the government, following neutral criteria and evenhanded policies, extends benefits to recipients whose ideologies and viewpoints, including religious ones, are broad and diverse." (quoting the Supreme Court's 1995 Rosenberger decision)Â
Though Ms. Wigg can now attend these meetings, this case illustrates the intense hostility to religion festering in public schools. Her own peers and her principal attempted to keep her out of a harmless meeting of schoolchildren in the library.
The simple act of Rosa Parks sitting near the front of a bus spawned the civil rights movement. Will Ms. Wigg’s win mark the beginning of a civil rights movement for Christians in public schools?