Court Monitor • Feb 15, 2004

Seventh Circuit Dismisses Lawsuit over Illegal Aliens

Text Reader

A steady stream of illegal aliens has been pouring into the United States. Many of them find jobs at lower wages that displace American workers. The federal Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit covers the states of Wisconsin, Illinois and Indiana. Recently it entertained a citizens' attempt to stop the hiring of illegal aliens. Plaintiffs sued a meat-processing company known as IBP, which has a plant in Joslin, Illinois. They alleged that the plant hired illegal aliens in droves to suppress the wages, to the detriment of "all persons, authorized to work in the United States, who have been or are now employed" there. The district court dismissed the lawsuit, holding that this issue should instead be addressed by the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB). Wages at plants are ordinarily the domain of unions, and their disputes are to be heard by the NLRB in the first instance. On appeal, the Seventh Circuit took its own look at the complaint. First, it observed that "[i]f the allegations are true, managers at IBP have committed hundreds of felonies." The court recited allegations that "about half of the employees at IBP's Joslin plant are aliens who cannot lawfully work in the United States." Plaintiffs claimed that "IBP alerts its unauthorized employees to stay away the days when immigration officials conduct inspections." Plaintiffs further alleged that "[w]hen immigration officials do manage to catch and remove aliens not allowed to work (or be) in the United States, IBP pays 'recruiters' to smuggle them back into the country and immediately re-employs them under new aliases and new bogus identification." The complaint said that IBP arranged with immigrant-welfare organizations to refer aliens to IBP for employment. What would the benefit be for the employer? Plaintiffs alleged that "wages at the Joslin plant are depressed by about $4 per hour compared with what IBP would have to pay if the labor force included only U.S. citizens plus aliens holding green cards." Prosecution of employers for hiring illegal aliens has not been a high priority, except for a well-publicized investigation of Wal-Mart. There were no criminal cases pending against IBP over hiring aliens, nor is it known if any of the shocking allegations is true. We may never know, because the Seventh Circuit dismissed the case prior to discovery of the facts. Judge Easterbrook held that even if the allegations are true, plaintiffs cannot proceed with their lawsuit. Plaintiffs had invoked the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act, and asserted that a RICO enterprise consisted of IBP, the "recruiters" smuggling in aliens, and the immigrant-welfare organizations. This is impossible, according to Judge Easterbrook, because he said they have "divergent goals": recruiters want to earn more for their smuggling, but IBP wants to pay them less. Baker v. IBP, Inc., 357 F.3d 685 (7th Cir. 2004) Few would agree that a recruiter of illegal aliens has divergent goals from an employer of the same. Dismissal on this technicality leaves workers with only one recourse against displacement by illegal aliens: defeating their representatives in Congress who fail to require federal agencies to enforce our immigration laws.