Court Monitor • Mar 14, 2004

Court Turns Away from Foreign Law

Text Reader

The Supreme Court has increasingly embraced foreign law to liberalize American social policy, but there is one field resistant to this trend. Plaintiffs' attorneys will not be citing foreign law for personal injury lawsuits, which often yield large verdicts in America that shock the rest of the world. The first tort reform was the Warsaw Convention signed in 1929. Protecting the fledgling international airline industry against lawsuits, this treaty was ratified by the United States in 1934 and dutifully applied ever since. It set a limit of merely $75,000 on liability for accidents on international flights, and the industry thrived for decades as a result. That limit was not lifted for American passengers until 1997, and even now Americans must prove an "accident" to recover for damages on an international flight. Usually it is obvious whether there was an "accident" within the meaning of the Warsaw Convention. An ambulance-chasing attorney cannot recover in connection with a flight that most passengers view as uneventful. But the meaning of "accident" was not obvious in the tragic death of Dr. Abid M. Hanson, who died on a flight from Athens to San Francisco despite a lack of injury to any other passengers. Dr. Hanson had suffered for 20 years from an extreme sensitivity to second-hand smoke. Embarking on a family vacation to Cairo in December 1997, he was shocked to learn that international flights still allowed smoking. For the outbound flight, the airline gave him a seat far from the smoking section. On his return the airline was not so accommodating. Seated only three rows in front of the economy class smoking section, his wife demanded that he be reseated further away from its smoke. The flight was nearly full and the stewardess said she was "too busy" to help. As Dr. Hanson was engulfed by cigarette smoke, his wife reiterated for a third time her demand that her husband be moved. The stewardess, refusing to take action herself, invited the doctor's wife to ask other passengers if they would like to switch seats. The situation deteriorated, as the doctor never did switch seats. Two hours into the flight, the smoke allegedly increased and Dr. Hanson's own inhaler medication ran out. He walked to the front of the plane to reach fresher air but then collapsed and died. Another doctor, a friend, administered CPR and oxygen to no avail. The cause of death was not determined by autopsy for religious reasons. The doctor's wife sued the airline, Olympic Airways, and received a judgment for $1.4 million by the district court even though there were eleven empty seats in economy class and plaintiff was free to ask others to switch seats. Affirmed on appeal by the Ninth Circuit, the airline took its defense to the Supreme Court. Justice Thomas, writing for the Court, rejected the narrow views of "accident" adopted by English and Australian tribunals. He held that the airline's inaction towards Dr. Hanson was indeed an "accident" for which the airline could be held accountable. Olympic Airways v. Husain, 124 S.Ct. 1221. Justice Scalia, in dissent, noted the irony in the way the Court had adhered to foreign law on issues of capital punishment and homosexuality, while rejecting foreign interpretations of a treaty. It is, indeed, strange that the Court rejects our allies' views about liability under treaties, but adopts foreign preferences to change U.S. social policies.