Court Monitor • Mar 28, 2004

California Court Defends Republicanism

Text Reader

It is not every day that a California court stands up for republican government. Yet that is exactly how an appellate court ruled in deciding against a tribe of American Indians. Litigation concerning Indian tribes dates back to Chief Justice John Marshall, who expanded federal court power from 1801 to 1835 until he took one step too far. When Marshall invalidated a Georgia law concerning activity on Indian land there, President Jackson reportedly rebuffed him and said, "John Marshall has made his decision, now let him enforce it!" Jackson then allowed Georgia to continue dealing with Indian territory in its state as before. The High Court has not interfered with military issues since, affirming even the internment of Japanese-Americans during World War II. But on business matters the Court has continued to obstruct application of state laws to Indians. For example, in 1998 the Supreme Court granted Indian tribes immunity from lawsuits to enforce contracts, regardless of whether the contracts were executed on or off a reservation. In 1991, the Court prevented a state from suing a tribe to collect taxes on cigarette sales to non-Indians. In 1977, the Court removed jurisdiction from a state court to order a tribe to obey a state law limiting the quantity of caught fish. But those issues are picayune compared to the gambling behemoth. Many tribes have exploited their freedom from state laws by operating lucrative casinos not otherwise allowed. States remain mostly powerless to apply their own laws against gambling to Indian reservations. The gambling, in turn, creates an enormous political incentive for tribes to support candidates and referenda promoting it. In 1998, for example, the Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians (the Tribe) contributed towards passage of Proposition 51 to build, at public expense, a new passenger rail line to its casino. The Tribe donated a whopping $7.5 million to political candidates in that year alone. The Tribe, however, did not file the disclosure statements required by state law in a timely manner. Citing this and other violations of the California Political Reform Act, the Fair Political Practices Commission sued. The Indians objected immediately, insisting that they enjoy tribal sovereign immunity against lawsuits. If states could not apply their laws within tribal lands, as Chief Justice John Marshall held nearly 200 years ago, then the Tribe felt it could not be sued over how it spends its political cash. By a 2-1 margin, a panel of the Third Appellate District of the State of California disagreed. Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians v. Fair Political Practices Comm'n, CO43716 (3rd App. Dist. Mar. 3, 2004). The court held that neither the U.S. Constitution nor any treaty or statute grants Indians tribal immunity. Instead, the Tenth Amendment and Article IV, Section 4 confer authority on the states to enforce their campaign finance laws against Indians. The Tenth Amendment reserves to the states powers not delegated to the federal government, and Article IV, Section 4 is the Guarantee Clause requiring states to maintain a republican form of government.