It did not take long for the Court that threw out the acknowledgment of God in the Pledge of Allegiance to give the green light to marijuana growing in its jurisdiction. In one year the Ninth Circuit banned the Pledge and then tied the hands of the Bush Administration in combating drugs. As with immigration and gay marriage, liberals now advance their cause at the state rather than the national level. This time the issue is the growing and use of the narcotic marijuana.
California and eight other states have legalized so-called medicinal marijuana, whereby people can lawfully smoke marijuana based merely on a doctor's recommendation despite federal drug enforcement policy.
Diane Monson, a Californian complaining of severe chronic back pain and painful muscle spasms, grew marijuana for her own use. She cited the California Compassionate Use Act as authority for her actions regardless of federal policy.
On August 15, 2002, local sheriff deputies and federal agents convened at Monson's home. The local deputies found that Monson's marijuana plants were in compliance with state law, but the federal agents from the Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA) insisted otherwise. A three-hour siege ensued involving the local Butte County District Attorney and the U.S. Attorney for the Eastern District of California. The standoff culminated with the seizure and destruction of six cannabis plants on Monson's property by the DEA agents.
Federal agents have destroyed marijuana plants in California before, often without prosecuting the growers. Pot-smoking is so prevalent now that it is doubtful the federal government could obtain convictions, so it usually does not dare prosecute a case of alleged medical use.
After the raid, Monson and others sued for an injunction to bar the Bush Administration from destroying their marijuana plants again. The district court refused. But the California Medical Association and California Nurses Association sided with the marijuana growers on appeal. So did the State of California and City of Oakland.
On December 16, 2003, the Ninth Circuit ordered the district court to issue a preliminary injunction against the federal government. Raich v. Ashcroft, 352 F.3d 1222 (9th Cir. 2003). By a 2-1 margin, the judges cited conservative decisions limiting federal power in order to tie the hands of the Bush Administration. They cited chapter and verse of the legacy of Chief Justice Rehnquist, who has assiduously reasserted state sovereignty against federal encroachment in areas ranging from gun control to domestic violence.
The Ninth Circuit even bypassed a famous precedent limiting how much wheat a farmer could grow on his own land. That decision, Wickard v. Filburn, 317 U.S. 111 (1942), for decades stood for the proposition that federal power under the Commerce Clause is virtually limitless over economic issues.
Marijuana use under a doctor's recommendation is plainly economic, but the Court strained to hold otherwise. Pot growers in six other states within the Ninth Circuit can now expand their operations: Alaska, Arizona, Hawaii, Nevada, Oregon and Washington.
Even supporters of marijuana admit that it causes cancer, memory loss, increased sexual activity, weight gain and dangerous driving, none of which today's teenagers or the general public need. In Pot We Trust?