Imagine Earl Williams' surprise when he was charged with trespass for removing sand and gravel from his own land in Nevada. He had purchased property 65 miles north of Las Vegas and was later told he could not sell sand and gravel from it.
The federal Bureau of Land Management (BLM) accused him of trespassing on federal property. Mr. Williams surely wondered how his government could charge him with trespass for actions he took on his own land.
The federal agents insisted that the government reserved rights in all "valuable minerals" on Mr. Williams' land based on the Pittman Act (1919), which opened western land to private ownership. Although sand and gravel were not "valuable minerals" when the statute passed, the bureaucrats claim they are now.
Environmentalists already prevent landowners from chopping down their own trees, and now the U.S. government blocks some property owners from transferring ordinary deposits from their own land.
Government showed no interest whatsoever in Mr. Williams' sand and gravel before he started removing them. Only when the landowner tried to be productive did our government become interested and demand that he stop.
When Mr. Williams protested, the BLM ruled against him. When he appealed, the Interior Board of Land Appeals decided against him again. Stuck with sand and gravel that he could not remove, Mr. Williams unloaded the property. The rulings against him surely depressed his sales price, but he had evidently had enough.
The new owner, aptly named BedRoc Limited, had the financial resources to carry the struggle into federal court. Predictably, the district court judge also decided against private property rights.
The case moved on to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, notorious for its anti-government rulings on everything from illicit drugs to the Pledge of Allegiance. But when it comes to ruling against free enterprise, the Ninth Circuit happily obliged: it dealt the landowner another defeat.
The Supreme Court had split 5-4 on a similar issue two decades earlier. Then, the Court held against a property owner in declaring that the federal government had rights in gravel based on another federal statute. Watt v. Western Nuclear, Inc., 462 U.S. 36 (1983). But this time on appeal, six Justices sided with the landowner with only three against. BedRoc Ltd., LLC v. United States, 124 S. Ct. 1587 (Mar. 31, 2004).
Chief Justice Rehnquist and Justice O'Connor had dissented from the earlier Western Nuclear holding that gravel was a "mineral" protected by federal law. Yet they protected that ruling in BedRoc, and Justices Kennedy and Scalia joined them in elevating precedent over free enterprise. Despite their previous ruling, these four Justices held for the landowner, noting that even if gravel is a "mineral," it does not qualify as a "valuable mineral" under federal law.
Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Breyer, went further in describing the prior precedent as "faulty reasoning." They felt that government should not have had a right to sand or gravel as either a "mineral" or a "valuable mineral."
Justice Souter, settling in with the most liberal wing of the Court, joined Justices Stevens and Ginsburg in embracing government interference with the free market. Quoting a foreign justice for guidance on how to interpret a statute, they asserted government ownership of sand and gravel on private land in Nevada.
The long duration of this litigation illustrates how hostile the judiciary is to property rights. All rulings were against free enterprise until the final decision of the Supreme Court.