If convicted felons had voted in 2000, Al Gore would be president. Florida has more than enough felons who would have voted Democratic to have swung that state to Gore. This one-sided impact has led to a legal campaign to persuade activist judges to rewrite state laws to allow felons to vote. The lawyers are using the Voting Rights Act which prohibits a voting qualification that "results" in an abridgement of the right to vote on account of race.
Jalil Abdul Muntaqim is an African-American serving a life sentence at the Shawangunk Correctional Facility in Wallkill, New York. New York law prohibits him from voting as long as he is in jail or on parole, which is for the rest of his life. Muntaqim alleges that this disenfranchisement violates the Voting Rights Act because of the disproportional impact on minorities. He contends that blacks and Hispanics constitute less than 30% of the New York voting-age population, yet are more than 80% of the inmates in state jails.
When the district court in upstate New York dismissed his complaint, a high-powered New York law firm took up his cause on appeal to the Second Circuit. Attorneys at the Brennan Center for Justice at the prominent NYU School of Law chimed in with a supporting amicus brief.
They had much on their side in the language of the 1982 revision of the Voting Rights Act. Earlier, in 1980, the Supreme Court had held that racially neutral state laws only violate the Voting Rights Act if they are motivated by a "discriminatory purpose." Without proof of such purpose, a mere discriminatory result did not violate federal law.
But the 1982 amendment removed the requirement of a wrongful purpose. It invalidates any "voting qualification ... which results in a denial or abridgement of the right of any citizen of the United States to vote on account of race or color . . . ." 42 U.S.C. § 1973(a). In 1996, the entire Second Circuit addressed whether this law prohibits disenfranchising felons in New York and the Court split 5-5, leaving the issue unresolved.Â
On Muntaqim’s appeal, however, a three-judge panel upheld the statute while urging a "definitive resolution by the United States Supreme Court."Â Muntaqim v. Coombe, 2004 U.S. App. LEXIS 8077 (2d Cir. Apr. 23, 2004).
It was only the pro-federalism mark of the Rehnquist Supreme Court that salvaged the disenfranchisement statute. The Second Circuit relied on the "clear statement" rule: "if Congress intends to alter the usual constitutional balance between the States and the Federal Government, it must make its intention to do so unmistakably clear in the language of the statute." Gregory v. Ashcroft, 501 U.S. 452, 460-61 (1991).Â
Notably lacking from the Voting Rights Act is any clear statement that Congress intended to prohibit state disenfranchisement laws. Moreover, the Act cannot extend beyond the power of the Fourteenth Amendment on which it is based, and at ratification 29 of 36 states had provisions in their constitutions prohibiting or authorizing prohibition of voting by persons convicted of felonies or infamous crimes. As of 2002, 48 out of 50 states restricted voting by felons.
The Fourteenth Amendment itself explicitly recognizes the power of states to disenfranchise criminals. Section 2 of the Amendment applies "when the right to vote at any election ... [is] abridged, except for participation in rebellion, or other crime ...." States have always been able to deprive felons the right to vote as part of their punishment.
"So while the Second Circuit said no to felons voting, it invited the Supreme Court to address the issue on a future appeal."