On April 21st, one of the most closely watched state cases in the country held its oral argument. The Michigan Supreme Court considered a challenge to government seizure of private property for development by another private entity. County of Wayne v. Hathcock. No one doubts that government can take and pay for private land for public uses, such as constructing highways or parks. But the taking of private property for another private use is a horse of a different color.
Advocates of this expanded eminent domain cite "public purpose," which goes far beyond "public use." Two decades ago General Motors evoked memories of its "what's good for GM is good for America" in persuading a city to take private land for it to build a new factory.
That was the famous Poletown case, named after the section of Detroit that replaced a blighted area of homes with a new auto plant. The Michigan supreme court upheld that taking in a decision that has remained controversial ever since. Poletown Neighborhood Council v Detroit, 410 Mich. 616, 304 N.W.2d 455 (1981).
City planners and some businessmen favor urban renewal that replaces bad areas with productive factories. Crime and vice are replaced by good jobs, and everyone seems better off.
Not so, says the free enterprise think tank Mackinac Center for Public Policy, a prominent critic of governmental interference with the free market. Government impedes the efficient magic of the invisible hand and, besides, the Michigan constitution simply does not authorize this.
Claiming that it would create 30,000 new jobs and $350 million in revenue, developers proceeded to obtain regulatory approvals to build a massive technology park next to Detroit Metropolitan Airport. Call the "Pinnacle Project," it has accumulated 98% of the 1,300 acres desired.
But several owners possessing 2% of the land objected, and refused to sell their property at the offered price. The developers retaliated by filing a "Resolution of Necessity and Declaration of Taking" to condemn the owners' land and take it by eminent domain. Â
The owners replied: where is the "necessity"? The developers had not even decided on the specific uses for the property yet, nor had rezoning even been obtained.
The owners were encouraged by a similar case in Arizona last year, where an appellate court invalidated an attempt by a city to take property for redevelopment. Bailey v. Myers, 76 P.3d 898 (Ariz. Ct. App. 2003). There the Bailey family fought the City of Mesa in order to save their family store, Bailey's Brake Service, from the City's redevelopment project. The Institute for Justice, now based in Arizona, successfully obtained a victory for the family in court.
The court held that "the City does not propose to take the Baileys' property for a traditional public use such as a street, park, or governmental building. Nor is this taking essential for the provision of public services or for reasons of public safety or health. Instead, the completion of this redevelopment project will result in the property becoming part of a privately owned retail center with stores, restaurants, and office space." 76 P.3d at 904.
But the owners outside of Detroit airport have not fared so well. To their horror, the Michigan Court of Appeals held in an unpublished opinion that eminent domain is based on "two types of necessity. One is whether the proposed use, purpose, or improvement itself (the Pinnacle Project) is necessary. The second type of necessity is whether the taking of the individuals' real property is necessary for that use, purpose, or improvement (i.e., whether defendants' property is necessary for the Pinnacle Project)." It upheld the taking under the latter rationale. County of Wayne v. Hathcock, 2003 Mich. App. LEXIS 1042, *11 (Apr. 24, 2003).
This issue is now in the hands of the Michigan Supreme Court, with a decision expected this summer. At oral argument, one of its Justices went so far as to indicate that private ownership is subject to a taking for anything that "is legitimate for the government to do."