Wrestlers were tossed and pinned to the mat last year in a stinging decision by the D.C. federal district court. After 171 wrestling teams had been eliminated by colleges in the past two decades, the coaches unsuccessfully sued to save their sport from gender quotas.
Judge Emmet Sullivan, appointed by the first President Bush, ruled against the wrestlers by citing chapter and verse from an amicus brief filed by the extremely feminist National Women's Law Center. Despite overwhelming evidence that men are far more interested in sports than women, the court upheld a federal policy mandating gender quotas for college teams.
The Carter and Clinton Administrations developed guidelines under Title IX, though contrary to it, urging colleges to make the proportion of men and women on competitive teams equal to their proportions among the general student body. That requires eliminating men's teams until the number of their participants matches the lower number among women's teams even though men are far more interested in competitive sports than women.
Wrestling is masculine, athletic and extremely cheap. All that is needed is a large mat and one to two dozen male competitors to fill all the weight classes.
Yet this "proportionality test" has forced jettisoning large numbers of men's teams in wrestling and other sports, discarding 519 men's teams during the 1980s and 1990s. In a report prepared by the General Accounting Office (GAO), 31% of the responding schools admitted that they cut the men's teams to meet gender equity goals or requirements.Â
Typically four times as many non-recruited men than women try out for teams, yet gender equity requires cutting all those men. Bill Pennington, "Want to Try Out for College Sports? Forget It," N.Y. Times (9-22-02). Debbie Yow, the athletic director for the University of Maryland, admitted that "the men's [lacrosse] coach has been turning players away while the women's coach has been literally begging women to fill out the roster." John Tierney, "Why Don't Women Watch Women's Sports?", Week in Review, N.Y. Times (6-15-03). "In order to keep the number of male and female players balanced to comply with Title IX, the men's lacrosse team has had to reduce its roster."
Not ones to shy from adversity, the wrestlers appealed the judgment against them. The National Women's Law Center filed another amicus brief, seeking endorsement of its mindless, outcome-based equality.Â
Eagle Forum Education & Legal Defense Fund defended the wrestlers, decrying the harm caused by gender quotas in sports. National Wrestling Coaches Ass'n v. Dep't of Ed., 2004 U.S. App. LEXIS 9426 (D.C. Cir. 2004) (Williams, J., dissenting). Judge Williams, appointed by President Reagan, agreed.
"Federal support for postsecondary education totaled over $119 billion in 2000, well over 40% of the nearly $278 billion spent by all postsecondary institutions that year." Id. at *59 (Williams, J., dissenting, citing National Center for Education Statistics, Digest of Education Statistics 2002 at Tables 343-46 and 363). In light of this financial leverage, he called "rather plausible" the wrestlers' claim that the federal proportionality test has caused the elimination of men's teams.
Had Judge Henderson, appointed by the first President Bush, joined her conservative colleague, the wrestlers would have prevailed. Instead, she quietly joined the liberal opinion of Judge Edwards, a President Carter appointee. Judge Edwards could not cite the National Women's Law Center arguments in the face of briefs disproving them. Instead, he dismissed the case by seizing on two mere words by the wrestlers' attorney at oral argument.
Counsel had stated that without the quota-like proportionality mandate, wrestlers had "better odds" of retaining their college teams. Judge Edwards, writing for the D.C. Circuit, said "better odds" of relief are not enough to confer standing on a party challenging a federal guideline.
In dissent, Judge Williams aptly criticized this; probabilities underlie the legal standard for standing, and a requirement of proof of certainty should not be erected to impede this meritorious claim.
Thus by a narrow 2-1 margin, the gender proportionality test for college sports survived. But as its senselessness is exposed, this mindless equality is losing ground in the rational debate.