In recent months, Michigan, Pennsylvania and West Virginia have each addressed the growing demand by homeschoolers to compete in high school sports. Yet the three states reached three different conclusions.
In Michigan, the Thomas More Law Center sued on behalf of numerous families seeking access by their home educated children to public school sports teams. The Michigan Court of Appeals, however, upheld the exclusion of them from the teams. Reid v. Kenowa Hills Public Schools, 261 Mich. App. 17 (Mar. 2, 2004).
Michigan high schools belong to a statewide athletic association that insists on banning homeschoolers. The penalty against a school that allows one to play is very harsh: forfeiture of any victory, striking of its team records, and exclusion of the school from championship tournaments.
Two decades ago, the Michigan Supreme Court held that students at private schools lacking a band class had a right to enroll in a comparable local public school class. Snyder v. Charlotte Public School Dist., 421 Mich. 517 (1984). Similarly, students at private schools lacking electives such as science, shop and advanced math can enroll in those courses at public school.
But the public school sports association and the Court of Appeals refused to allow homeschoolers on school teams, despite being taxpayer-funded. The court rejected plaintiffs' claim that the discrimination violates the equal protection clause.
The court insisted that the exclusion of homeschoolers is justified to "to eliminate recruiting or the use of 'ringers' in high school athletics." 261 Mich. App. at 31. A "ringer" is an impostor so talented that he influences the outcome. Even if an extraordinary "ringer" did appear, he would simply play at the public school for which he is zoned and there would be no risk of recruitment by a different school. The court could not cite any examples of ringers or any actual problems caused by them.
West Virginia's courts sensibly reached a conclusion opposite to Michigan's when confronted with similar discrimination against homeschoolers. Daniel and Christie Jones challenged the exclusion of their son Aaron from participation on the public middle school wrestling team. The statewide school association prohibited his participation, and the state Department of Education affirmed that decision. Â
Kanawha County Circuit Judge Duke Bloom knows unfairness when he sees it, overturning this ban on homeschooled students. He observed that such students can participate in school band, and should also be allowed to compete athletically. He ordered the state agency and school association to rewrite their rules to allow participation. In May, the West Virginia Supreme Court refused to reconsider the decision, thereby enabling Judge Bloom's ruling to stand.
Pennsylvania has taken a middle ground, permitting local school districts to admit or exclude homeschoolers from teams. Each year it becomes a contentious issue for school boards, but the trend is towards increasing access. Schools allowing home educated students to compete in sports has now grown to over 50%, but in April one Lancaster County school board voted to study the issue further while continuing to exclude such students from school teams.
Michigan State's Education Policy Center performed a study in March 2003, finding that more than 5% of the children there may now be homeschooled. Excluded from school sports, this population of more than 120,000 students has started its own successful leagues. In early June, Michigan sports writers voted to include them in all-state honors, and last year the NCAA approved the eligibility of over 100 such athletes nationwide.