Public schools and federal courts have much in common, ranging from lifetime tenure, lucrative pensions, and hostility to religion. Asking one to punish the other is a bit like asking Hillary to curb Bill Clinton's behavior.
Federal district court in New Jersey recently held in favor of the Ridgewood Board of Education, again. Several years ago the same court had dismissed this suit by parents challenging a highly offensive questionnaire imposed on their children at public school.
On appeal of the initial dismissal, the Third Circuit reversed, holding in favor of the parents and ordering the district court to consider their claims. On remand, however, the district court came to the same conclusion as before and dismissed the case, again. C.N. v. Ridgewood Bd. of Ed., 2004 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 9803 (D.N.J. May 28, 2004).
The survey, called "Profiles of Student Life: Attitudes and Behaviors," asked 156 questions in an objectionable manner. Answer choices painted a distorted picture of the frequency of drug use, sexual activity, suicide attempts, and other undesirable conduct.
One question inquired of students "how many times, if any, in the last 12 months have you used LSD?" One answer allowed more than 40 times of LSD use, thereby indoctrinating all students that drug use is pervasive and implying that frequent uses are acceptable.
Students who answered zero to the LSD question would have felt like they were oddballs, as the choices of frequency were "0"; "1"; "2"; "3-5"; "6-9"; "10-19"; "20-30"; or "40+" times. Likewise, students who have not attempted to kill themselves were led to think that they were the strange ones. Question 101 was: "Have you ever tried to kill yourself?" and the choices were "No"; "Yes, once"; "Yes, twice"; "Yes, more than two times."
In school, tests are the most powerful tool for inculcating student attitudes. What a teacher says in class can go in one ear and out the other, but all students are trained that test questions are legitimate and that their future depends on picking the correct answers. Â
Students rarely, if ever, are experienced or courageous enough to reject an examination question as improper and refuse to answer it on that basis. More often than not, a student would be punished with a poor grade or worse for challenging authority.
One student did treat this offensive survey with disdain and intentionally filled it out improperly, including marking an incorrect race to describe his own ethnicity. But a teacher was watching and compelled him to retake the examination after school as though the survey were mandatory and legitimate.
In a court trial, no competent attorney would permit these intrusive and loaded questions to be asked of a witness. But in school, where propaganda goes unchallenged, the students had no realistic alternative.
Despite 100% completion rate on the surveys and the detention of one student to redo his, the district court held that the survey was "voluntary." This was contrary to a finding by the U.S. Department of Education, which independently stated that "the District violated [federal law] when it administered the [survey] without the prior written consent of the" parents. The Department of Education had specifically found that the survey was funded with federal education (Goals 2000) funds, students were required to participate, the survey asked questions about prohibited topics, and the school district failed to obtain prior written consent from the parents.
This defeat of the parents in court may be an example of losing the battle but winning the war. The outrage against the survey from the publicity over the lawsuit led to passage of a New Jersey law requiring prior written parental consent for such questionnaires in the future.