As Congress debates reining in judicial power, all nine Justices agreed on their own initiative to limit certain court authority. Norton v. Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance, 124 S.Ct. 2373 (June 14, 2004). The environmental subject matter was not earth-shattering, but the Court's reasoning is. At issue was whether organizations can sue the Department of the Interior under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA).
"We begin by considering what limits the APA places upon judicial review of agency inaction," Justice Scalia wrote on behalf of every Justice. He concluded that the APA precludes judicial review of most types of agency inaction, thereby limiting court jurisdiction.
Environmental groups, led by the Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance, had sued the federal government to block access by off-road vehicles (ORVs) to federal lands in Utah. About half of the entire State of Utah is owned by the federal government, totaling 23 million acres. Congress has denied access by motorized vehicles to some of that land, while delegating to the Secretary of the Interior authority to manage other land known as "wilderness study areas" (WSAs).
As recounted in an America's Future column in January, the environmentalists prevailed before the Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit in obtaining judicial review of the Department's handling of access to the WSAs. At issue was whether a court could order the Department to ban ORVs, and the Tenth Circuit ruled that courts do have this power.
We predicted that on appeal the Supreme Court would rein in this judicial power, and it did -- unanimously. "The prospect of pervasive oversight by federal courts over the manner and pace of agency compliance" with myriad congressional directives was found to be unjustified.
Until now, courts had entertained all sorts of challenges to inaction by agencies. The "failure to act" is even listed by the APA as grounds for bring a lawsuit against the government.
But Justice Scalia and the entire High Court sharply curtailed the power of the federal judiciary to consider such lawsuits in the future. They announced a new objective: "to protect agencies from undue judicial interference with their lawful discretion, and to avoid judicial entanglement in abstract policy disagreements which courts lack both expertise and information to resolve."
The Court thereby limited judicial review to inaction violating specific laws. It further confined judicial power in those cases to ordering that some action be taken, without specifying what the action should be.
Under this narrower authority, the Court then made quick work of the demand by environmentalists to compel the Department of the Interior to limit access by ORVs. Inaction by the government with respect to ORVs, without any law specifically requiring action, is outside of the new limits on judicial power. The Court thus found lack of jurisdiction to address the inaction.
Next was the environmentalists' claim that plans considered by an agency can serve as the basis for a court order compelling action by that same agency. Nothing doing, the Court held, declaring that "a judicial degree compelling immediate preparation of all the detailed plans" at a location "would divert [agency] energies from projects throughout the country that are in fact more pressing."
With this unanimous decision, Justice Scalia finally obtained full support for his philosophy of judicial restraint. No longer merely a lone wolf in dissent, Justice Scalia's conservative legal philosophy attained a striking triumph.