Court Monitor • Aug 7, 2004

Court Ends Politically Correct Sentencing

Text Reader

On June 24, the Supreme Court rendered its biggest decision of the term. Newspapers nationwide carried headlines that this decision cast doubt on the American system of punishing criminals. At issue was a husband's "kidnapping" of his wife. Robert Howard Blakely, Jr., a man with a history of psychological problems, abducted his estranged wife at knifepoint from their home in Washington State in order to persuade her to dismiss her action for divorce. When their 13-year old son returned from school, Blakely ordered him to follow them in another car. Armed with a shotgun, Blakely took his wife to a friend's house in Montana, who turned him into the police. He pled guilty to second-degree kidnapping involving domestic violence and use of a firearm, a crime punished by 49 to 53 months in jail under the applicable state sentencing guidelines. At the sentencing hearing, however, the judge declared defendant to have acted with "deliberate cruelty," magic words that trigger very harsh punishments under a domestic violence statute. The judge sent Blakely to prison for 90 months, three years more than he thought possible. That was not what Blakely pled guilty to, and he objected. The judge held his own hearing, without a jury, to justify his increased sentence. Blakely insisted that this deprived him of his constitutional right to a trial by jury. The judge disagreed, and the state court of appeals affirmed. The Washington Supreme Court refused even to hear the case. But the U.S. Supreme Court accepted the appeal. With "centrist" Justices unsympathetic to this type of defendant, it seemed impossible for him to cobble together a majority in his favor. But the Court's moderates were powerless this time against a left-right coalition that occasionally forms on important issues. Blakely v. Washington, 2004 U.S. LEXIS 4573 (2004). The conservative wing, Scalia and Thomas, was joined by the liberal flank of Stevens, Souter and Ginsburg. Justices O'Connor, Kennedy and Breyer were left to carp ineffectively in dissent. Â Justice Scalia penned the decision, building on a precedent that had tossed out another politically correct sentence enhancement. Apprendi v. New Jersey, 530 U.S. 466 (2000). Apprendi invalidated a "hate-crime" statute authorizing a judge to double a sentence if he thought the defendant acted with a purpose to intimidate because of "race, color, gender, handicap, religion, sexual orientation or ethnicity." The problem then and now is the deprivation of defendants' Sixth Amendment right to trial by jury by judicial capriciousness. To conservatives a jury trial is the strongest bulwark against the criminalization of politically incorrect acts. The reversal of the 90-month sentence for wife kidnapping brought Chicken Little cries from moderates O'Connor and Kennedy. They claimed the sky will fall for thousands of sentences handed down by judges, including the judicial practice of increasing jail time for defendants if they dare testify in their own defense. Justice O'Connor, joined in her dissent by Kennedy, Breyer and Rehnquist, noted that as of March 31st there were 8,320 criminal sentences being appealed, but that hardly justifies keeping the current system. The Blakely case is already having a nationwide effect in reducing the power of judges to add extra years to a prison sentence.