Court Monitor • Sep 15, 2004

English Spoken Here

Text Reader

The City of Altus, Oklahoma has an "English-only" policy. It requires that "all work related and business communications during the work day shall be conducted in the English language." Exceptions include "to communicate with a citizen, business owner, organization or criminal suspect in his or her native language due to the person or entity’s limited English language skills." The City applies its English-only policy to include the "face to face communication of work orders and directions as well as communications utilizing telephones, mobile telephones, cellular telephones, radios, computer or email transmissions and all written forms of communication." The policy does not apply to "strictly private communications between co-workers while they are on approved lunch hours or breaks or before or after work hours . . . if City property is not being used for the communication." Nor does the policy "apply to strictly private communication between an employee and a family member so long as the communications are limited in time and are not disruptive to the work environment." The purpose of the city policy is "To facilitate communications between City employees, to prevent employees who speak only English from feeling excluded, and to address potential safety concerns." Hispanics are affected most, and several Spanish-speaking employees sued to invalidate the policy. They claimed the English-only rule creates a hostile work environment, amounting to racial harassment in violation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. Many decisions and even a regulation of the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) lend support to plaintiffs’ claim. The EEOC’s official position is that an English-only rule at work is presumed to be "burdensome" to employees un-less limited to "certain times" and is "justified by business necessity." 29 C.F.R. §Â 1606.7(a). Nevertheless, the district court in Oklahoma held in favor of the English-only policy. Sanchez v. City of Altus, 2004 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 3252 (Feb. 20, 2004). It cited prior decisions, including one by the Ninth Circuit in 1993, establishing that there is no recognized burden on bilingual employees in being required to speak English in job-related activities. Garcia v. Spun Steak Co., 998 F.2d 1480 (9th Cir. 1993). The City employees who sued were bilingual, and the court held that the City could properly require them to speak English.  In following the Ninth Circuit precedent, the Oklahoma court rejected the EEOC regulation because courts do "not defer to an administrative construction of Title VII which was not supported by the statute." This decision upholding the English-only policy would not change even if it resulted in the teasing of some employees. An abusive work environment occurs only if ridicule among employees is of "such severity or pervasiveness as to alter the conditions of their employment." Most courts have likewise upheld English-only rules by employers. Customers and those looking for jobs can seek establishments that encourage English conversations. Employers can require English of their staff under this and similar decisions, and can post this sign to attract business: "English Spoken Here."