Court Monitor • Jan 19, 2005

ERA Blocks Disciplining Male Prisoners

Text Reader

Most violent crime is committed by males, and it should surprise no one that violent men in jail are disciplined differently from violent women. Men can and sometimes do kill while in prison, and fights among male prisoners can quickly become deadly. Â The Massachusetts prison system has a special Departmental Disciplinary Unit (DDU) for men who violate the rules in a serious manner. Not for the faint of heart, this Unit sends the most violent inmates to solitary confinement, sometimes for extended periods. But Massachusetts is home to a state Equal Rights Amendment, promoted under the guise of advancing rights for women. This is the same ERA that one of its Supreme Court Justices invoked in late 2003 as justification for requiring the issuance of gay marriage licenses. ERA is often used to promote a unisex agenda rather than to help women. This time a Massachusetts court invoked ERA to interfere with strict discipline of men who do not follow the rules in prison. DuPont v. Wyzanski, 2004 Mass. Super. LEXIS 462 (Super. Ct. 2004). Far from helping women, the court used ERA to disrupt law and order for male prisoners. The court held that the prison system cannot treat men and women differently unless the highest legal standard of "strict scrutiny" is satisfied with respect to incarcerated men and women. A disciplinary code that applied only to imprisoned men did not meet that heightened standard, in the eyes of the court. Under this new rule, a difference in treatment between men and women can only be upheld if the state proves that it has a compelling interest for the difference, and that the different treatment is narrowly tailored to that interest. This is the most stringent legal standard of review ever devised by courts, and is the same high level of scrutiny used to protect our most cherished freedoms such as speech. The prison officials defended their disciplinary system by pointing out that "the assaults between male inmates are far more violent" than those by women. But such logic was unavailing to the unisex mindset of a court determined to impose its own unusual views on the rest of us. The court even relied on a prior Massachusetts decision favoring prostitutes in the name of equality. "A female charged with prostitution or night walking would be entitled to dismissal . . . [if] the police department or the prosecutor's office followed an unjustifiable policy of selective enforcement against female prostitutes and not male prostitutes." The court seemed unfazed by its foray into what it admitted was micromanagement of the prisons. Anticipating a "floodgate potential for suits to be brought by current and former inmates," the court addressed this concern merely by certifying the issue for appeal to the appellate court. One can only wonder what, if any, differences in treatment between males and females could survive a legal challenge in the courts of Massachusetts. If different treatment of men and women in prison is illegal, then sensible allowances in schools for differences between boys and girls would likely be invalid also.