There is one thing in common in most homes raided by the FBI for alleged criminality: pornography. Cause and effect? Few would dispute the possibility. In 2003, University of Toronto psychiatrist Ron Langevin released a study showing that the worst sex criminals viewed pornography at disproportionately high levels compared to less violent criminals. Â
Nevada Senator John Ensign is a rising conservative star, winning his seat easily two years after nearly toppling one of the most powerful Democratic incumbents, Senator Harry Reid. Senator Ensign knows that pornography is not something we should be providing to federal prisoners during their incarceration. As a congressman in 1996 he pushed through the "Ensign Amendment," which prohibits the use of federal funds by the United States Bureau of Prisons (BOP) to "distribute or make available any commercially published information or material to a prisoner ... [when] such information or material is sexually explicit or features nudity."
For decades the federal courts have dismantled protections against obscenity, thereby unleashing a torrent of pornography on our society under the guise of "free speech." But surely taxpayers should not have to pay for the distribution of this pollution to inmates.
The BOP, after all, lawfully deprives convicted felons of many things taken for granted by most citizens. Communication with the outside world is sharply limited for federal inmates, breaking down the spirit of many a prisoner after just a few years of incarceration. Persons convicted of any federal felony cannot possess a firearm or ammunition for the rest of their lives.
But the courts confer special rights on pornography, and it was only a matter of time before a judicial activist invalidated the Ensign Amendment. After a district court judge courageously upheld the ban on pornography for prisoners, three judges on the Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit unanimously held in favor of porn. Ramirez v. Pugh, 379 F.3d 122 (3d Cir. 2004). That court ordered a new hearing on whether the Ensign Amendment is justified, implying it was not.
"We do not find the connection between the Ensign Amendment and the government's rehabilitative interest to remain obvious upon consideration of the entire federal inmate population, including those prisoners not incarcerated for sex-related crimes," the Court held. Id. at 129. But even if judges want prisoners to have access to pornography, why should taxpayers be forced to foot the bill for its distribution?
This decision contradicted a ruling by the D.C. Circuit on the same issue. In 1998, that circuit upheld the Ensign Amendment on the grounds that withholding pornography from prisoners was reasonably related to their rehabilitation. Amatel v. Reno, 156 F.3d 192 (D.C. Cir. 1998). But this correct result was based on the wrong reason, as Congress does not need to justify its spending decisions for the courts. The court's rationale invited subsequent judicial supremacy.
Congress alone is authorized by the Constitution to make spending decisions. The judiciary has overstepped its authority, and mandating prisoner access to pornography invites public outrage. Should the next spending decision of Congress be to defund the courts?