Court Monitor • Nov 3, 2005

Teacher Wins Pro-Family Ruling

Text Reader

Public school teachers dedicate their lives to providing a tax-funded, standardized education, yet when their own kids are ready to start school, teachers often take advantage of alternatives like private or home schools. One district, in an attempt to silence this implied criticism, wound up doing just the opposite. The Sixth Circuit upheld the parental rights of a public school teacher in Steubenville, Ohio, who sent his son to Catholic schools, was therefore denied promotion, and ultimately fired. Barrett v. Steubenville City Schools, 388 F.3d 96 (6th Cir. 2004). Substitute teacher Patrick Barrett sued for compensation in federal court. He ultimately won an affirmation of the right of parents to guide their children's education without government interference. After substituting for much of the 1999 school year at Wells Elementary School, Mr. Barrett was offered a job interview for a full-time teaching position there. Before the interview, he was informed that he would not receive a permanent post unless his son enrolled in one of the district's schools. Barrett refused to do so, since his son had happily attended a local Catholic school since kindergarten. Consequently, Barrett was denied permanent employment. According to the superintendent, the school board wanted teachers to enroll their children in the city's schools because it "looked good" to other parents in the district. Barrett was to send his son to government-run schools and keep him there . . .or else. The media are full of stories about public schools that chronicle falling academic standards, interspersed with articles about drug busts and even kids who go on a killing rampage. Based on this plentiful information, any rational parent has the right to conclude that private schools are a good alternative, and has the right to act accordingly. However, this right seems to disappear if the parent is employed by a very touchy school district. Finally surrendering to intense harassment by his superiors, Barrett enrolled his son in Steubenville High School for the 2000-2001 term. However, even then no promotion appeared. Furthermore, the superintendent told Barrett that returning his son to Catholic school would be held against him. Barrett's son disliked the government school and Barrett switched him to a Catholic high school. The superintendent promptly fired Barrett for being "disloyal." Incensed by this maltreatment, Barrett sued the superintendent and the school board. The Court of Appeals held in Barrett's favor. "Both the Supreme Court and this court have repeatedly recognized that parents have a fundamental right to raise their children, including directing their children's education." The court concluded, "Barrett has a constitutionally protected fundamental right to educate his child at the school of his choice." The court thus affirmed a long line of precedents that defend the intrinsic role of parents as the primary teachers of their children. This ruling stands in welcome contrast to the many anti-family rulings that emanate from the judiciary. Education professionals know the problems of the current educational system. Like any other parent, they have the right to promote their children's educational progress by removing them from the failed schools, and many do. Government can take our money to fund its schools, but fortunately cannot yet force us to send our children there.