Court Monitor • Nov 9, 2005

A Man's Home is His Castle? A Man's Swamp Should be His Moat

Text Reader

In a great contribution to Western Civilization during the Dark Ages, Benedictine monks drained thousands of swamps all over Europe. The draining not only eliminated breeding grounds of disease, but also freed up huge tracts of fertile land for cultivation and development. But our federal courts have set us back more than a thousand years to before the time when man freely applied his ingenuity to enhance the world he inhabits. United States v. Rapanos, 376 F.3d 629 (6th Cir. 2004). John Rapanos, his wife, and their wholly owned land-development companies were charged under state and federal law with having filled in and drained boggy terrain on their property in Michigan. For this heinous crime, Mr. Rapanos received three years probation and was forced to pay $185,000 in fines. Afterwards, the federal government filed and won a civil suit in district court against the parties concerned for filling in 54 acres of wetlands on several additional parcels. The Supreme Court accepted the Rapanos' appeal of this case on October 11, and will hear it early next year. The government relied primarily on the Clean Water Act in harassing the Rapanos. This law was passed in 1972 with the intent of protecting the water supply from pollution. But courts, the Army Corps of Engineers, and EPA have since defined wetlands as any land that is submerged, supports aquatic plants, and is somehow connected to navigable bodies of water, no matter how remotely. Through this expansive definition of a wetland, the federal government assumes control over virtually every body of water in the nation. A property owner must first request permission from the Army Corps of Engineers and obtain a permit before draining his property. Even then, if the Corps desires to protect the wetlands, the owner is stuck with a useless swamp that produces only clouds of disease-bearing mosquitoes. The federal government took the tenuous link between a wet area and navigable waters to an absurd degree in order to take control of Rapanos' property. Their primary wetlands site was connected to navigable waters by a drain, which flowed into another drain, which drained into the Kawkawlin River, which was connected to the Saginaw River, which flowed into Saginaw Bay on Lake Huron. In other words, the property was connected to federal jurisdiction only by five degrees of removal. Wetlands not only diminish the value of the property they occupy, but also consume useful space. Were it not for the government regulators, the Rapanos would have been able to construct usable property on one of the plots that would have brought jobs and tax revenues to the entire community. Instead, the Rapanos have a useless bog and the town has more mosquitoes. Unless reversed by the Supreme Court, this precedent is yet another advance in power by the federal government at the expense of free enterprise and private property. It is a reminder of how far we have departed from the Reagan Administration, which enjoyed popularity by attempting to curtail regulatory burdens. It is long overdue to recognize that a man's home is his castle, and he should be able to drain his moat as he sees fit.