Court Monitor • Feb 12, 2005

Missouri Witchhunt Backfires

Text Reader

Heartland Academy, a non-denominational Christian school, takes in troubled teenagers whom no one else can handle. After all other attempts at discipline have failed, parents and juvenile courts send youngsters to Heartland in rural northeast Missouri to see what can be done for them. The school is generously financed by Charles and Lori Sharpe, and does not accept funding from local, state or federal governments. Charles Sharpe is the founder of the successful Ozark National Life Insurance Company. Â Charles Sharpe testified as to his purpose: "My wife and I both had very humble beginnings, but we made some money and we decided we were going to spend our money on youth. . . . We just want to see if we can help change our young people into a real life." Heartland Academy Community Church v. Michael Waddle, 317 F. Supp. 2d 984 (E.D. MO 2004). He has donated $50 to $60 million of his own money to this project, in addition to devoting virtually all of his personal time and energy to it. The Sharpes opened their arms to children who had never once had a family meal, and gave them structure and purpose in their lives. The Sharpes themselves personally took 14 troubled girls into their own home, one as young as 11 years old. The children would learn to go to sleep at a normal hour and eat meals on a regular basis. They were soon going to church three times a week. Their problems of drugs and sex were addressed with restrictions on telephones and other communications with the outside world. This program was successful until the New York Times and a local juvenile officer named Mike Waddle entered the picture in 2001. "Sharpe [is] a politically influential backer of organized school prayer and conservative lawmakers, and a longtime friend of John Ashcroft, the United States attorney general and former senator from Missouri," the Times reported in a story attempting to humiliate all of them. The embarrassment consisted of publicizing an unauthorized form of punishment at the school, which required teenaged troublemakers to wade into manure. Mr. Sharpe disapproved as soon as he learned about this discipline and it was quickly terminated, but the story became a way to bash conservatives and perhaps even prosecute Sharpe and his employees. Juvenile officer Waddle embarked on a campaign to exert power over the school and see what more could be found. Mr. Waddle had not received any complaints about the school, but nevertheless he began a highly invasive investigation. Waddle and a sheriff went out to the facility to view where the manure discipline had occurred, and found the students unfazed by the experience. No child had been physically injured by it, but the government officials were unhappy with the matter-of-fact descriptions elicited from the students, as though there was nothing abusive about it. Six students were then removed to the police station for in-depth questioning. One of the youths talked about how he had brought a gun to his former school to kill a teacher and a fellow student. Another described how he had been a drug dealer, and committed theft and battery. A third juvenile told Waddle that "the government should stay out of his business," and that it was evil and trying to shut down the school. Another youth told Waddle that "Pastor Charlie will be talking about you guys in church again.". . . Criminal charges were brought against six staff members over the manure incident. But the first person was acquitted at trial, and the remaining charges were subsequently dropped. Meanwhile Waddle continued investigating and questioning students. He and the sheriff asked questions about more than the manure incident, including interrogations about what Charles Sharpe was preaching. Additional boys were removed from the school to the police station over Sharpe's objection and without notifying their parents. Waddle obtained a search warrant and seized lists of the students' parents from the school. He then sent a letter to them stating that 68 felony charges had been filed against five school employees and he was considering taking action to assure that no child would continue to live in that environment. Other corporal punishment at the school became a target for investigation. The school tallied points for unacceptable behavior and when the total reached 13, the youth received swats. No adult was allowed to administer swats while angry, but the school did allow a male adult to swat a female youth and the local officials demanded an end to that. One night an extremely violent and very strong girl went out of control and no one was available except Sharpe to impose order. She had a pattern of behavior that included attempting to bang her head against the wall. Sharpe had no choice but to use swats to discipline her. Later, a female staff member suffered a fractured rib in trying to restrain the same girl. Yet government officials complained that the girl exhibited bruises from the discipline, as though that somehow proved abuse. On October 30, 2001, Waddle and local officials orchestrated a raid on the school to forcibly remove 113 boarding students. A judge later found that closing Heartland, over the care of children . . . was his clear priority." One staff member was only alerted to the raid by the Associated Press, which read him a copy of legal documentation over the phone. The story might have ended there with ruination of the Academy had it not been for one of its graduates, an immigrant from Romania, who could not believe this was happening in America. He videotaped the raid, and what he recorded shocked everyone, including federal district Judge E. Richard Webber. The video reveals how hard the troubled youths fought to stay in the disciplined environment of the Heartland Academy. "The videotape records a large policeman attempting to physically force a young girl through the door of a bus as she clung with a firm grip on a rail to prevent the use of force against her." Later, "when the cameras were pointed at the bus, the screams became louder inside and outside the bus." In subsequent litigation, Judge Webber quoted the Romanian's comments such as "this is the United States of America; this is wrong; this should not be happening." Judge Webber concurred: he "summarizes concisely and about as well as words can describe the scene at the Heartland Christian Academy on October 30, 2001." To the extent the children had reachable parents, they were irate about the government interference with discipline at Heartland. Most were able to return their children to the school based on a new court order, but not without threats by the juvenile officer that "a return of your child to Heartland Christian Academy could result in the Court entering its order to take your child into emergency protective custody for your failure to provide a safe and appropriate environment for your child or referral to other agencies including law enforcement for further review and action if any." A shocking 35 of the children had been forcibly removed from the school without any court order authorizing it. When Heartland Academy sued Waddle and others, they tried to claim absolute immunity from liability for their actions. Finding that juvenile officer Waddle had "deep prejudices against Heartland," the judge held him liable for his actions. The court entered an extraordinary injunction against Waddle and any other juvenile officer from taking "into protective custody any child or children from Heartland Academy" without notice and a hearing unless there is truly imminent danger to the child. In August, the judge ordered Waddle to pay more than $800,000 in legal fees to Heartland Academy. The New York Times did not report Sharpe's ultimate victory.