Court Monitor • Feb 27, 2005

Court Rebuffs the Military

Text Reader

"The Solomon Amendment cannot condition federal funding on law schools' compliance with it." With those words, judicial activists on the federal Third Circuit struck down the Solomon Amendment, which conditioned federal funding for universities on their fair treatment of military recruiters. Forum for Academic and Institutional Rights (FAIR) v. Rumsfeld, 2004 U.S. App. LEXIS 24598 (3d Cir. Nov. 29, 2004). Â Rep. Gerald Solomon (R-NY) sponsored his Amendment in 1994. "Tell[] recipients of Federal money at colleges and universities that if you do not like the Armed Forces, if you do not like its policies, that is fine. That is your First Amendment right[]. But do not expect Federal dollars to support your interference with our military recruiters." 140 Cong. Rec. H3861 (May 23, 1994). His co-sponsor, Rep. Richard Pombo (R-CA), was more blunt: he implored his colleagues to "send a message over the wall of the ivory tower of higher education" that schools' "starry-eyed idealism comes with a price. If they are too good - or too righteous - to treat our Nation's military with the respect it deserves[,] then they may also be too good to receive the generous level of taxpayer dollars presently enjoyed by many institutions of higher education in America." Id. at H3863. President Bill Clinton signed this into law, but ever since our most liberal graduate schools have looked for ways to discriminate against military recruiters while soaking up federal handouts. Meanwhile they have lobbied Congress to craft numerous exceptions that allow them to ban military recruiters under various circumstances that include alleging lack of student interest. The U.S. Constitution, Article I, Section 8, clause 12, authorizes Congress to raise and support a military, and "recruiting is the key to an all-volunteer military." Id. at H3861 (quoting Rep. Solomon). Section 8, clause 1 further confers on Congress the authority to "lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States." Its clause 18, commonly known as the "Necessary and Proper Clause," leaves no doubt that Congress can "make all Laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers." Article II likewise confers broad powers on the President for the military. Yet a 2-1 panel majority on the Third Circuit blocked enforcement of the Solomon Amendment. Dissenting Judge Aldisert noted that "the majority has created new law, totally unsupported by binding precedent. In doing so the majority selects ... not a single case where an act of Congress was not only authorized by various Clauses in Articles I and II, but commanded by them." Congress has the power to forcibly draft graduate students into military service, which is the alternative if recruitment fails. The Marines could even convert entire universities into boot camps if deemed to be in the nation's interest. The only limit on quartering troops is to protect residents in peacetime. In wartime, like now, Congress may advance the national interest. But where there is a will for judicial activism, there is a way. The panel majority held that the Solomon Amendment violates the First Amendment right of universities to disapprove of the military policy concerning homosexual conduct. Quoting the precedent allowing the Boy Scouts to exclude homosexual scoutmasters, BSA v. Dale, 530 U.S. 640 (2000), the panel mandated that federally supported universities can exclude military recruiters. But in contrast to the Boy Scouts, universities take billions of federal dollars and thus should be subject to congressional conditions on that funding. It seems doubtful that this decision will survive the eventual review by the Supreme Court, or the wrath of Congress once it realizes it can directly terminate its funding of the enemies of our military.