Fed up with pro-drug advertisements preying on captive audiences in public buses and subways, Congress used its spending power to cut off funds to transit authorities that run the ads. Rep. Ernest Istook (R-OK) inserted the "Istook Amendment" into the federal spending bill for FY2004, and it compelled local officials to choose between taking taxpayers' money or running ads critical of drug laws. Â
Proponents of legalized marijuana went to court to overturn the will of Congress and the American people. In an all-too-familiar pattern, a federal judge declared this statute to be unconstitutional. ACLU v. Mineta, 319 F. Supp. 2d 69 (D.D.C. 2004). Judicial supremacy again eroded congressional spending power.
The U.S. Supreme Court consistently, and often unanimously, opposed efforts to undermine federal laws against addictive drugs in America. It has repeatedly slapped down efforts by some states to bypass federal prohibitions on narcotic prescriptions and sales.
The High Court has likewise been solicitous of the spending power of Congress, upholding a broad array of conditions placed on money allocated to state and local governments. Even on the topic of alcohol regulation, which is expressly reserved to the states by the 21st Amendment, the Supreme Court upheld federal power to increase the drinking age by placing conditions on highway funding.
But the Supreme Court will not have a chance to affirm congressional spending power in this case. Why not? Because the Department of Justice took the extraordinary action of refusing to defend a law passed by Congress. The Justice Department notified the Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit that it was withdrawing its defense of the statute.
Its decision not to defend the federal law is very unusual. The Wall Street Journal observed that this "could serve as a warning to Congress that it can't assume the Justice Department will support the controversial riders that lawmakers have been adding to funding bills if those riders are challenged in court" (Jan. 26, 2005).
A slick ad sparked this case after it was declined by the District of Columbia transit authority for fear of losing federal funding. It displayed attractive, upright citizens standing behind prison bars with a woman in the foreground. Underneath, large print proclaimed "1 IN 3 ADULT AMERICANS have tried marijuana ...." Then came the clincher: "Federal marijuana laws can arrest or imprison every one of them just for simple possession."
While it is alarming how many Americans are imprisoned for decades for drug crimes, the federal government prosecutes drug traffickers rather than mere users. Surely Congress need not spend billions fighting drug dealers while simultaneously allowing pro-drug ads to be thrust upon a captive audience in federally financed transportation.
Yet in a terse, two-page letter, acting Solicitor General Paul D. Clement implied that transit authorities could only ban ads encouraging drug use if they simultaneously banned ads discouraging their use. Speaking for the Justice Department, Clement described its view as resulting from "well established Supreme Court precedent."
That "well established" precedent is only a 5-4 decision invalidating restrictions on cable pornography. United States v. Playboy Entertainment Group, 529 U.S. 803 (2000), and a 5-4 decision striking restrictions on lawyers under the federally funded legal services program, Legal Servs. Corp. v. Velazquez, 531 U.S. 533 (2001). Meanwhile, many precedents affirming congressional power to place conditions on its spending were circumvented, such as the prohibition on abortion referrals by some recipients of federal aid that was upheld in Rust v. Sullivan, 500 U.S. 173 (1991).