Court Monitor • Apr 17, 2005

Scouts Forced out of School

Text Reader

In February the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) threatened the Boy Scouts with massive litigation if they did not abandon all their school charters. These lawsuits would not be against the Boy Scouts, but against any sponsoring school. This is no idle threat. The ACLU has sued the Boy Scouts 14 times during the past 25 years. Â Last fall, the ACLU sued the Pentagon and forced it to drop its charter of the Boy Scouts for activities on federal property. The case was settled by the Pentagon only upon agreement to end its sponsorship of the Scouts. The F.E. Warren Air Force Base in Cheyenne, Wyoming, sponsors two Boy Scout troops. When those sponsorships are up for renewal this spring, these troops will have to look for different sponsors. Caving into the ACLU in that case will leave 422 Boy Scout troops stranded without a sponsor. U.S. Senator Mike Enzi (R-WY) is himself an outraged Eagle Scout. "The Boy Scouts ... teach character, a sense of community and a respect for public service," Enzi said. "A lawsuit in this instance is not the answer." The ACLU insists that government sponsorship of Boy Scout troops is unconstitutional for two reasons: first, that scouts pledge allegiance to God, and second, they vow to be "morally straight." The immensely beneficial influence of 120,000 Scout troops on millions of boys evidently means nothing to the ACLU. The ACLU garners fat attorney's fees from liberal federal judges in lawsuits against public institutions involving the Ten Commandments, Bibles in monuments, and scouting. To protect the schools against costly lawsuits, the Boy Scouts recently responded to the threat by initiating a large-scale pullout. They are requesting that private parent-teacher organizations or local churches replace schools as their sponsors. The Scouts hope that their access to schools will not be affected by this change. When schools open their doors to community groups, scouting enjoys the same access as any other activity. But not all schools allow community access, and even those that do often impose time restrictions. Adult-led classes work best in the early evening, and community access can be tailored to that timetable; scouting, in contrast, may function best immediately after school. Many Members of Congress are former Boy Scouts. Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist has introduced S.642 (the "Support our Scouts Act of 2005") to restore the federal government's sponsorship of the Boy Scouts and to prohibit the courts from limiting federal support of any youth organization. After being humiliated by judges in the Terri Schiavo case, who thumbed their noses at a congressional subpoena and at emergency federal legislation, Congress may seek to retrieve lost power and prestige by protecting the Boy Scouts against the courts. Congress can simply order federal courts not to hear cases against the Boy Scouts. If there is any doubt about whether judges will comply, a clause authorizing impeachment for violations should ensure obedience.