For 17 years, the federal Sentencing Guidelines have dictated how long convicted defendants are to be sent to jail. Their animating purpose was to bring consistency to a system that had degraded into the luck of the draw, with each a man's fate a function of the courtroom in which he landed. Â
Under the Guidelines, discretion previously available to federal judges had been replaced with tables and formulas automatically setting the punishment. The Guidelines put an end to the media mockery of disparate sentences for similar crimes. Above all, the federal government fears embarrassment in the media.
However, the impersonal, computer-like operation of the Guidelines soon became their own object of scorn. Liberals disliked the lengthy sentences for repeat offenders, most notably for drug crimes. Some judges even resigned from the federal bench in protest about how the Guidelines forced them to imprison defendants for terms thought to be manifestly unjust. In response to criticism, however, officials simply blamed the Guidelines.
Conservatives grew to oppose how the Guidelines marginalized juries, making them almost irrelevant. Prosecutors eventually learned that they could game the Guidelines by obtaining minor convictions and then presenting their real case before the judge at sentencing. The system enabled judges to make new findings of facts to ratchet up sentences in ways the jury never considered.
Better yet, prosecutors found that by threatening to do this they could avoid jury trials altogether, as defendants would plead guilty and accept months in jail rather than face a sentence of many years under the Guidelines. The percentage of prosecutions that end in a plea bargain rather than a trial skyrocketed to an astounding 97.1% by 2002, and some federal courthouses now only see a handful of criminal trials each year. An agreement by the prosecutor and defendant to a Guideline range virtually guaranteed a particular sentence, a practice that some judges have grown to dislike.
Political moderates joined prosecutors in defending the Guidelines for the efficiency and consistency they brought to an otherwise chaotic system. The four moderate Justices on the Supreme Court, Breyer, O'Connor, Kennedy and Rehnquist, liked the Guidelines accordingly.
Last June, Justice Scalia shook our criminal justice system in overturning a prison sentence that went beyond the confessed guilt. In United States v. Blakely, Justice Scalia reasoned for the remaining five-Justice majority that if a jury did not find a defendant guilty of a crime, and the defendant did not admit to having committed a crime, then he should not be sent to jail. That simple logic sent the DOJ into a tizzy, reflecting how far from its moorings our criminal justice system had gone.
The aftershock came on January 12th, when the Supreme Court addressed a direct challenge to the Guidelines based on Scalia's Blakely decision. In United States v. Booker and United States v. Fanfan, a coalition of liberals and conservatives lined up on one side against the moderates on the other. The latter did everything they could to salvage their beloved Guidelines against legal attack. Justice Breyer, who initially helped write the Guidelines nearly two decades ago, was the point man for the defense.
The result was the most confused disagreement imaginable. The Blakely majority affirmed their basic point that defendants should not be sentenced beyond guilt established by jury or plea. However, in an extraordinary gambit, Justice Breyer relinquished the most important aspect of the Guidelines, the provision making it mandatory on judges, and instead reclassified them as advisory. That move enabled him to peel off from the Blakely majority the other Clinton appointment, Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Breyer thereby enjoyed a new 5-4 majority.
He then proceeded to engage in an unprecedented display of statutory gerrymandering to salvage his progeny. He cut out statutory provisions and invented replacements. To convert the Guidelines to be permissive rather than mandatory, Justice Breyer excised the statutory provision telling judges how to sentence, which left no standard for an appellate court to review a sentence. Justice Breyer declared that a standard of "unreasonableness" should be used in reviewing sentences. He sheepishly added, "The ball now lies in Congress' court."
Congress is supposed to give the Court orders, not vice-versa. Instead of cleaning up the mess that the Court created for itself, Congress might profitably do some soul-searching on how much money it has poured into this branch of government known as the Judiciary.