The U.S. Supreme Court has allowed a flood of pornography on the internet that can be found on the computers of so many perpetrators of violent sexual crimes against women and children, including convicted murderer Scott Peterson. The problem is not just that the courts consistently side with smut peddlers; it is that the courts reinterpret the Constitution to prevent laws from standing in the pornographers' way. The pornography industry is much larger than professional football, basketball, and baseball combined, and its high profit margins would make most Fortune 500 companies blush.
Clinton appointed Judge Gary L. Lancaster essentially declared federal obscenity laws to be unconstitutional and unenforceable. U.S. v. Extreme Associates, 352 F. Supp. 2d 578 (W.D. Pa. 2005). It is very rare for a federal judge to dismiss an indictment, but he threw out an indictment against defendants who admitted that they sold obscene material over the internet.
Federal courts have been friendly terrain for smut dealers ever since their favored son, pornography attorney Abe Fortas, was elevated to the U.S. Supreme Court by President Lyndon Johnson. Each year the obscenity in our communities increases, and crimes incited by pornography flourish. Though rarely publicized, viewing pornography is the hobby of most perpetrators of the awful crimes that we increasingly hear about on the news.
The defendants in Judge Lancaster's courtroom brazenly argued that federal laws against obscenity are unconstitutional. They insisted that neither Congress nor anyone else has any power to stand in the way of their selling obscene materials over the internet.
Judge Lancaster took his cues from liberal law professors who insist that the U.S. Supreme Court decision in Lawrence v. Texas invalidated federal obscenity laws. Harvard Professor Laurence Tribe, for example, declared last year that "the Court's holding in Lawrence is hard to reconcile with retaining the state's authority to ban the distribution to adults of sexually explicit materials identified by, among other things, their supposed appeal to what those in power regard as "unhealthy" lust, or the state's power to punish adults for enjoying such materials in private, whether alone or in the company of other adults." 117 Harv. L. Rev. 1893, 1945 (2004).
Judge Lancaster agreed. "The Lawrence decision can be reasonably interpreted as holding that public morality is not a legitimate state interest sufficient to justify infringing on adult, private, consensual, sexual conduct even if that conduct is deemed offensive to the general public's sense of morality."
Judge Lancaster noted that the conservative dissent in Lawrence, joined by Justices Rehnquist, Thomas and Scalia, predicted that the Lawrence ruling would cast doubt on the constitutionality of our nation's obscenity laws. Lawrence, 539 U.S. 558, 590 (2003) (Scalia, J., dissenting). They were right, Judge Lancaster held.
By invalidating federal obscenity laws, Judge Lancaster has continued the approach of our courts to render the American people helpless to stop the rising tide of pornography that engulfs our society and incites heinous crimes. Women and children are left to cope with a society of predators under the spell of pornography.