Court Monitor • May 29, 2005

Judge Jones Saves Life by Limiting Jurisdiction

Text Reader

On April 13, Judge Edith Jones delivered one of the best federal court decisions in a decade on behalf of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit. In Henderson v. Stalder, Judge Jones held that federal courts lack the authority to enjoin distribution of "Choose Life" license plates by the State of Louisiana. In the process she properly chided the lower court for overstepping its own power in the case. What a welcome ruling for a federal court to recognize meaningful limits on its authority! Federal judges have been unabashedly reinterpreting the Constitution to invalidate or impede countless state laws and actions, and Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg even criticized a congressional movement to withdraw court jurisdiction. Judge Jones sees no problem with Congress performing its constitutional duty to define court jurisdiction. She applied the Tax Injunction Act (TIA) to dismiss entirely the challenge to Louisiana's "Choose Life" plates. Judge Jones explained, "The TIA prohibits a federal court from 'enjoining, suspending or restraining the assessment, levy or collection of any tax under State law where a plain, speedy and efficient remedy may be had in the courts of such state.'" Louisiana charged an extra amount for those ordering the "Choose Life" license plates, and Judge Jones found that this charge was sufficiently similar to a tax to place the case outside of federal jurisdiction. After all, it really is no business of the federal courts how states raise revenue through license plates. Judge Jones adopted an approach that would work well in many troubled areas of federal jurisprudence, holding that federal courts lack jurisdiction simply because Congress took it away in the TIA. This ruling is an extraordinarily efficient and just way of disposing of the increasingly strained arguments raised under the Establishment Clause, which states that "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion." The plates do not mention religion and certainly do not represent the establishment of one. But rather than entertain a debate over what is or is not religious, the court simply dismissed the case as beyond its jurisdiction. Judges should welcome similar proposed bans on their passing judgment on references to God and depictions of the Ten Commandments. The ruling by the trial judge enjoining the State of Louisiana based on a distortion of the Establishment Clause illustrated how far our judiciary has departed from logic and the Constitution. When an unelected judge can prevent an entire state from allowing its citizens to express their preference for life, we are indeed in a legal crisis. Judge Jones provided the obvious answer: stay out, judiciary. Judge Edith Jones should be applauded for her implied support of congressional power to limit court jurisdiction. Congress limited federal jurisdiction pursuant to its constitutional authority, and the federal courts have the duty to honor the congressional directive. It is time for others in the judiciary to likewise uphold the Constitution as Judge Jones recently did.