On nearly the last day of its Term, the Supreme Court dealt a severe blow to the private ownership of land. No longer can persons or businesses feel secure that their own land is theirs alone. No more can one say that a man's home is truly his castle.
If a politically connected corporation wants your home or small business, it no longer has to negotiate with you on price; it can simply have your town take your property on the cheap for its benefit. If you use rented property, the result is even worse because most tenants have no rights when the property is condemned.
In the much-anticipated decision of Kelo v. New London, Justices Souter and Kennedy provided the swing votes in this 5-4 defeat of private property. Justice Stevens, another disappointing Republican appointment of the past, wrote the opinion for the Court.
Justice Stevens stated that "it has long been accepted that the sovereign may not take the property of A for the sole purpose of transferring it to another private party B, even though A is paid just compensation." Yet no one can count on those words, because the Court opened the floodgates to such takings.
The Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution states, "Nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation." The original meaning of "public use" is still its plain meaning today: a use like government services or transportation to serve basic needs of the public.
As Justice O'Connor noted in dissent, along with three others, "a law that takes property from A and gives it to B: It is against all reason and justice, for a people to entrust a Legislature with such powers; and, therefore, it cannot be presumed that they have done it." Calder v. Bull, 3 Dall. 386, 388 (1798). The Founders did not envision government growing so much in power that it could take one's home for the private benefit of another.
Yet that is what the Court just did to Susette Kelo and other victims. The City of New London sought to take their homes and turn their property over to a corporate development for Pfizer Inc. and others. America's Future filed an amicus brief in opposition, along with a car repair shop threatened with a taking for a private purpose. Wilhelmina Dery will be losing the home that she has lived in ever since she was born there in 1918. Ms. Kelo made substantial improvements on her house, which will be demolished.
But an even bigger loss from this ruling will be imposed on small businesses, as their goodwill and customer base are destroyed by forced relocation. The Court conceded that compensation is often inadequate in condemnation proceedings for the owner of the seized property, but declared that issue to be outside of the scope of this case..
Justice Thomas dissented separately to emphasize the original meaning of the Constitution. "When faced with a clash of constitutional principle and a line of unreasoned cases wholly divorced from the text, history, and structure of our founding document, we should not hesitate to resolve the tension in favor of the Constitution's original meaning."
Had just one of the three Republican-appointed Justices in the majority been willing to do that, the 5-4 majority against private property would have collapsed. Instead, Justice Kennedy wrote a creative concurrence that indicated his discomfort with expansive government takings, while allowing them anyway.
"The determination that a rational-basis standard of review is appropriate does not, however, alter the fact that transfers intended to confer benefits on particular, favored private entities, and with only incidental or pretextual public benefits, are forbidden by the Public Use Clause," Justice Kennedy wrote. He continued, "A court confronted with a plausible accusation of impermissible favoritism to private parties should treat the objection as a serious one and review the record to see if it has merit, though with the presumption that the government's actions were reasonable and intended to serve a public purpose." Ms. Kelo was not successful with this approach.