Court Monitor • Jul 19, 2005

Internet is Singing the Blues

Text Reader

Unanimity from the Supreme Court was the last thing expected in the lengthy litigation against peer-to-peer internet systems used to copy music. Yet the Court's decision against Grokster and StreamCast, two such systems, was an astounding 9-0. MGM v. Grokster. However, the Court actually split 3-3 on the fundamental issue at stake in the case: whether a software company can be held liable if its product is used to infringe copyrights. Predictably siding with Hollywood and the music industry was Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who implied that predominately infringing uses of an innovative product should render its maker liable. Equally predictable was how Justice Stevens, who famously saved emerging VCRs from destruction by the movie industry 20 years ago, sided with product developers. A massive number of amicus briefs flooded the Court on both sides of this issue. Media interests opposed new technology that threatens their power and profits, while internet supporters and chipmaker Intel Corp. filed briefs in favor of freeing innovation from court-imposed liability. The simple answer was to allow Congress to resolve this conflict, as it is far better situated to assess the economic and political benefits of unregulated peer-to-peer systems. But the media-types lacked the votes in Congress for their interests, and so asked the courts for legislation from the bench. The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit had held in favor of Grokster, which is one of many peer-to-peer file trading systems accessible on the internet. But Justice Souter, writing for the Supreme Court, held against Grokster in part because its name sounded to him like "Napster," a service he called "notorious." Justice Kennedy ultimately went to the Ginsburg-Rehnquist side and Justice O'Connor migrated to Breyer-Stevens view. Justices Souter, Scalia and Thomas never picked sides, opting instead to issue a compromise decision that resolved almost nothing. This compromise opinion of the Court held that an innovative technology is not liable to copyright holders simply because it facilitates infringement of copyrights. Rather, the Court emphasized that an affirmative effort to promote infringement is a necessary prerequisite to imposition of liability.