Federal district court Judge Blanche M. Manning is a product of Chicago Teachers College, which trains public school teachers. That was Judge Manning's career before becoming a lawyer and then being appointed by President Clinton to the federal bench in 1994 in Chicago.
The teachers' training probably influenced Judge Manning on the issue of religion in public life. Public schools have been inhospitable to religion ever since the Warren Court declared school prayer to be illegal in Engel v. Vitale (1962). Many chart the decline of American culture to that decision, which reinterpreted the Establishment Clause to drive prayer out of public schools.
Judge Manning is now extending that approach to prevent the United States from offering token assistance to the Boy Scouts of America. Winkler v. Chicago School Reform Bd. of Trustees, 2005 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 11561 (N.D. Ill. June 22, 2005).
For over two decades, the federal government has occasionally loaned materials to the Boy Scouts, allowing them to use surplus equipment at the quadrennial national Boy Scout Jamboree that attracts 40,000 Scouts and 300,000 parents and spectators. President Bush attended the 2005 Jamboree in Virginia.
Known as the "Jamboree statute," Section 2554 of Title 10 of the United States Code authorizes the Secretary of Defense to loan "cots, blankets, commissary equipment, flags, refrigerators, and other equipment and without reimbursement, furnish services and expendable medical supplies, as may be necessary or useful to the extent that items are in stock and items or services are available." The Boy Scouts must provide to the United States "good and sufficient bond for the safe return of such property in good order and condition, and the whole without expense to the United States."
Very few would genuinely view the Boy Scouts as a religious organization, or think that government cooperation with a jamboree violates the Establishment Clause. But by the mere stroke of her pen, Judge Manning invalidated a sensible law that has benefited hundreds of thousands of youths since its passage in 1972.
Judge Manning did not bother to hold a trial on the issue; she just enjoined the U.S. government from loaning the Boy Scouts materials under the Jamboree statute. She could cite no religious practices of the Boy Scouts, and was impervious to the undeniable benefits to the public of government cooperation in these large youth events. One may wonder if Judge Manning could also invalidate United States military operations themselves, as soldiers pledge allegiance "under God" and engage in substantial religious activities while camped in a manner similar to the Boy Scouts.
Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, himself a former Boy Scout, responded by securing near-unanimous Senate passage of a meaningless amendment to support the Boy Scouts. The amendment does nothing to restrain the judicial supremacists who are determined to strike down any assistance to the Scouts.
Democratic Senator Levin gushed, "Mr. President, we have no objection that I know of to this amendment. It does not purport to limit the jurisdiction of a Federal court in determining what the Constitution means. So we do not have any objection to it."
With a religious exemption in the statute and a clear Catholic position on record, the case seemed to be open-and-shut in favor of Seton Hall. But, alas, the plaintiff claimed that Seton Hall had waived its exemption by advertising a policy of nondiscrimination that included sexual orientation.
There is only one way to protect the Boy Scouts from a hostile and runaway judiciary: remove federal court jurisdiction over them. Despite passage by Congress each year of bills limiting or withdrawing federal jurisdiction on other matters, Bill Frist and others have so far refused to protect the Boy Scouts from judicial supremacists.