In October 2001, the Chief Juvenile Officer for the Second Circuit of Missouri forcibly removed 115 boarding students from Heartland Christian Academy (HCA) without a prior notice to HCA, its students or their parents. This removal was done on an "ex parte" basis whereby the judge authorizing it heard arguments only from one side and not the other.
The Juvenile Officer, Michael Waddle, exceeded even the court order in taking the students. There was no judicial authority to remove many of the students subsequently taken from the school.
Ordinarily this type of action by a state government would go unnoticed and there would be nothing the school or parents could do about it. In this case, however, a videotape was taken of the removal of children, showing they desperately tried to stay at the school. Viewers were shocked by the spectacle.
These students were not ordinary children. HCA was charitably devoted to helping troubled youths whom other schools could not handle. The sight of these children fighting to stay in school, as the government forcibly removed them under the pretext of a rescue, was remarkable.
HCA then sued Waddle and other officials. HCA successfully obtained a court order enjoining them from attempting another pre-notice or pre-hearing removal of children from the school, unless there is reasonable cause to believe that a particular child was in imminent danger of severe harm. Waddle appealed.
The Office of Attorney General of Missouri provided full legal support for Waddle and the other officials for nearly four years of litigation, appealing twice and even arguing that the Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit should "retract its statement" that held against the officials in the first appeal. But the Eighth Circuit held against Waddle and the other officials again. Heartland Acad. Cmty. Church v. Waddle, 427 F.3d 525 (8th Cir. 2005).
The Court reiterated the basic holdings in favor of parental rights established by the Supreme Court decisions of Pierce v. Society of Sisters, 268 U.S. 510 (1925), and Troxel v. Granville, 530 U.S. 57 (2000). In Pierce the Supreme Court held that a private school could successfully challenge a state law requiring attendance in public school; in Troxel the Supreme Court included guardians within parental rights. HCA was a boarding school, and benefited from both decisions.
"Waddle clearly interfered with Heartland's right to family integrity when he removed all of the boarding students from HCA in October 2001" because, as found by the trial court, "students were removed from HCA when there was no reasonable suspicion of child abuse." Waddle, 427 F.3d at 534.
This Court decision is noteworthy because it found the violation of multiple constitutional rights. "Waddle effected the wholesale removal of HCA's boarding students with ex parte orders or no orders at all in the absence of exigent circumstances." Id. at 535. The Court agreed that Waddle violated four separate constitutional rights: HCA's Fourth Amendment right against unreasonable seizure, its Fourteenth Amendment rights to family integrity and procedural due process rights, and its First Amendment freedom of association.
The Court added unusually harsh language to describe defendants' arguments. The Court observed that "it seems Waddle purposely misapprehends the District Court's injunction." Id. at 536. The Court exclaimed, "we find Waddle's claims to be preposterous." Charitably, the Court allowed that it "will chalk this one up to an attempt at zealous advocacy on the part of counsel and not to a fundamental inability to read and comprehend." Id.
A sorry chapter in overzealous child protection has ended in Missouri. Hopefully, state officials will think twice in the future before harassing private schools or seizing children without adequate basis.