Court Monitor • Jan 3, 2006

Judge Opens New York Schools to Worship

Text Reader

Driving by your local public school on a Sunday morning, would you expect to see worshipers streaming out singing church hymns and greeting a minister? That may soon become a reality in New York City, thanks to a November 16 ruling by Judge Loretta A. Preska. The Bronx Household of Faith v. Board of Ed. of the City of New York, 2005 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 28138 (S.D.N.Y. 2005). For years New York has prohibited using public schools as places of worship after school or on the weekend. The advocates of "separation of church and state" adamantly oppose use of government property for religious services. The Bronx is the poorest borough in New York City and one of the most blighted areas in our country. It is only fitting that a religious revival against secular suppression begin there. The Bronx Household of Faith and two individuals sued the Board of Education of New York City for the right to conduct Sunday worship in a public school. After all, groups of nearly every liberal ideology are allowed access to public schools, so why not allow a Christian worship service also? Nothing doing, New York City said, as it refused to allow a worship service on public school property. Its Board's Standard Operating Procedure expressly stated that "No outside organization or group may be allowed to conduct religious services or religious instruction on school premises after school. However, the use of school premises by outside organizations or groups after school for the purpose of discussing religious material or material which contains a religious viewpoint or for distributing such material is permissible." Why this intolerance towards worship in particular? Believers support worship, and non-believers think it is, at worst, silly. Who can genuinely object? Genuine or not, the religious censors fought the poor Bronx worshipers for four years to keep them out of a public school. Mercifully, Judge Loretta A. Preska, herself a graduate of religiously affiliated schools, finally held for the worshipers. In a decision that will almost certainly be appealed by ACLU-types, Judge Preska rejected the argument that allowing worship at a public school would violate the Establishment Clause. She cleverly cited a recent decision by Judge Sam Alito. In 2004 he held that it would be unconstitutional "viewpoint discrimination" "to exclude a group simply because it is controversial or divisive." Judge Alito thereby overturned a school policy forbidding evangelical leafleting in New Jersey. Child Evangelism Fellowship of New Jersey, Inc. v. Stafford Twp. Sch. Dist., 386 F.3d 514, 527 (3d Cir. 2004). New York City cited Justice O'Connor for its argument that censorship of the worship is appropriate, and even required by the Constitution. Judge Preska's rejection of that argument anticipates a change at the Supreme Court, where there will soon be at least four and as many as six votes for more religion in public schools. Justices Thomas and Scalia and Chief Justice Roberts can be expected to be firmly supportive of school prayer, and an expected Justice Alito would be also. Justice Breyer is increasingly supportive of religion, and has a daughter who became an Episcopal priest. Justice Kennedy also sometimes votes in favor of religion. Only three hard-core opponents of religion remain after Justice O'Connor's retirement, two of whom are expected to resign in the next five years: Justices Stevens and Ginsburg. Is a return to classroom prayer less than a decade away?