Court Monitor • Oct 22, 2006

Court Sets Girls' Sports Seasons!

Text Reader

There have been a whopping seven long decisions by federal Courts of Appeals in one narrow field of law in only the past several months. What important field is this? Terrorism, perhaps? Nope. The source of this intense judicial activity is Title IX, the federal law that prohibits sex discrimination in schools. Plaintiffs won, at least in part, four out of seven appeals. But in the cases concerning Title IX and sports, plaintiffs won a 3-0 sweep. Their biggest win came from the Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, in litigation that has already spanned five years. Communities for Equity v. Michigan High School Athletic Ass'n, 2006 U.S. App. LEXIS 20918 (6th Cir. Aug. 16, 2006). This case has been to the U.S. Supreme Court and back, and may go up yet again. The issue that has consumed the attention of our highest courts and millions of dollars in attorneys' time is whether the Michigan high school athletic association should be forced to schedule girls' basketball, volleyball and other sports in the same seasons as the boys'. The athletic association for Michigan high schools has a tradition of scheduling girls' sports in seasons different from the same boys' sports to enable the maximum use of limited sports facilities, but the feminists cry discrimination. Strict application of Title IX, and particularly its gender quotas for sports, has already forced colleges to eliminate many men's teams. Well over 170 men's wrestling teams have been eliminated in order to meet quota goals that match female participation in sports to female enrollment in school on a proportional basis. The obvious fact that girls are less interested in sports than boys is rejected by both feminists and judges, who demand equal treatment and percentages of boys and girls in sports with respect to enrollment. Just this summer Rutgers University, the large state college of New Jersey, abruptly eliminated four large men's teams to satisfy the Title IX quotas, stranding over 100 men who attend the college to compete on those teams. Public high schools nationwide now must eliminate a million boys from sports teams if they are going to comply with the same gender quotas. Michigan has been ground zero in the attempt to apply Title IX to high schools, and the Michigan High School Athletic Association has chosen to fight rather than roll over. It retained high-profile litigator Maureen Mahoney, who is herself a candidate for a judicial appointment, to defend a scheduling system based on efficient use of resources rather than mindless equality. But Ms. Mahoney has lost and lost again in this case. Even if Ms. Mahoney is discounting the $500-plus charges per hour for her time, she is surely racking up huge attorneys' fees on the other side that her own client will likely be forced to pay. After the Sixth Circuit ruled against her in 2004 by ordering the association to make its girls' sports schedule more like the boys', she obtained a special "grant/vacate/remand order (GVR)" by the U.S. Supreme Court compelling the Sixth Circuit to reconsider. On remand, the Sixth Circuit insisted it was right the first time and stuck to its original holding based on the Equal Protection Clause of the Constitution. Then it provided an additional, independent legal reason based on Title IX for ordering the association to change its sports scheduling. Two out of the three appellate judges held that the girls had a constitutional right to sports scheduling just like the boys, and all three judges held that the girls also had an independent right to win under Title IX. The Sixth Circuit's decision is one of the most sweeping in the country in commanding equal treatment of boys and girls. The Court ruled that because the association treated girls differently from boys, the burden shifted to it to provide an "exceedingly persuasive" justification. That test is almost impossible to satisfy, and it opens the door to many more lawsuits whenever and wherever a girl is treated differently from a boy. A more stunning defeat for the Michigan athletic association is difficult to imagine. While attorney Mahoney is likely planning another petition to the U.S. Supreme Court in an attempt to overturn this, the new Title IX basis for the decision makes it unlikely the High Court will take this case again. To add insult to injury, the association will likely be ordered to pay its adversary's large attorneys' fees.