Court Monitor • Oct 8, 2006

Judge Orders President Not to Spy on Terrorists

Text Reader

In a stunningly audacious opinion, a trial judge has prohibited President Bush from continuing his surveillance of phone and internet communications among suspected terrorists. Is it now unconstitutional, in the view of judicial supremacists, to protect our Nation against terrorists? The ACLU, the Council on American Islamic Relations and other organizations sued to stop the surveillance that President Bush admitted he had authorized. President Bush announced in his radio address of December 17, 2005 that he had "authorized the National Security Agency, consistent with U.S. law and the Constitution, to intercept the international communications of people with known links to al Qaeda and related terrorist organizations." President Bush first authorized this monitoring shortly after 9/11, and has reauthorized it at least 30 times since. Bush's revelation caused a huge stir among anti-war activists, but no political consequences. Evidently many Americans appreciate the monitoring of suspected terrorist activities for the protection of our Nation. But this lawsuit found a sympathetic audience in a federal courtroom. Federal District Judge Anna Diggs Taylor declared that Bush's monitoring program violates the First and Fourth Amendments and the Separation of Powers doctrine. ACLU v. NSA/Cent. Sec. Serv., 2006 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 57338 (E.D. Mich. Aug. 17, 2006). In basing her decision on the Constitution, the judge rendered Congress helpless to overturn the verdict. The government argued that this lawsuit should be dismissed in its entirety based on the "state secrets" privilege, which allows courts to dismiss lawsuits as non-justiciable when litigation would entail the disclosure of government secrets. The U.S. Supreme Court twice emphasized this privilege in prior cases. In a case arising from the Civil War, the Court dismissed on that basis a claim brought to recover for espionage services rendered during that war. More recently, the U.S. Supreme Court relied on the same privilege to dismiss claims brought by Cold War spies. In these cases, the courts never reached the merits of the claims, and simply denied them rather than risk the disclosure of government secrets. Judge Taylor invoked the "state secrets" privilege to prohibit plaintiffs from obtaining information about how the United States fights its war on terror. She rejected plaintiffs' attempt to obtain "data mining" information from the government in connection with its monitoring of terrorism. But Judge Taylor denied the "state secrets" privilege as a defense to the monitoring itself. She observed how Bush already admitted that he authorized the monitoring, and thus no release of additional information to plaintiffs is necessary to adjudicate that claim. The existence of the monitoring cannot be disputed. Judge Taylor cited how the monitoring was interfering with the confidentiality of attorney-client communications. Several attorneys indicated that their clients have discontinued communications with them due to the possible monitoring of their phone calls and emails. Scholars and reporters also complained about the chilling effect on their communications and how the eavesdropping interfered with their work. Congress has done nothing to curb judicial activism, and judges continue to outdo themselves with bolder and bolder examples of supremacist decisions. When a trial judge orders the President of the United States that he can no longer monitor suspected terrorist activity, something is badly awry.