As a private litigator, Chief Justice John Roberts' biggest win was Gonzaga University v. Doe. There he persuaded the U.S. Supreme Court to eliminate all private claims for violation of privacy in educational records. Prior to that decision, students could sue in federal court under the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA), which prohibits schools from releasing student records without prior consent.
A state court in Minnesota, however, has just given back to parents what attorney Roberts persuaded the federal courts to take away. Based on this new decision, Minnesota parents can again sue schools that violate their family's right to privacy in their children's school records. This new right to sue is in state, not federal, court.
Every year, public schools gather more and more data about students, much of it having dubious validity. Scores from psychological tests never seen by parents, for example, are inserted into students' records, as are other health records. Most parents have no idea what is in their children's records, and some of this information can be quite harmful if released to neighbors, potential employers, insurers, or other schools. The validity of some of the records may even be worth challenging, and mistakes are inevitable.
Most politicians would be ill-served by a public release of their educational records, and many withhold their academic performance from the public. Bill Clinton never released his academic record, which may undercut the media portrayal of him as an intellectual. Dan Quayle was the victim of a cruel campaign to force release of his academic record. Prior to the Gonzaga decision, each could have sued any school that released his records without his consent.
Minnesota seventh-grader Kevin Gayden's school record contained psychological and behavioral information about him, and also family histories. The record included an IQ score and information about his intellectual and functional abilities. A copy of his record was apparently discarded without any safeguards, and fell into the hands of other students at his school. Soon he was taunted as being "retarded," "stupid," and "dumb."
His mother sued the school and the jury awarded the family $140,000, plus attorneys' fees. The school appealed.
The Court of Appeals of Minnesota affirmed the jury verdict, holding that the Minnesota Government Data Practices Act provides parents with this remedy now lacking under FERPA. Scott v. Minneapolis Public Schools, 2006 Minn. App. Unpub. LEXIS 386 (2006). The Court of Appeals labeled its opinion as "unpublished," however, thereby attempting to prohibit its use by others. Such protection of public schools by courts is typical.
The public school argued, similar to the Gonzaga decision, that the Data Practices Act does not create a private cause of action by an individual student for violation of the Act. But the Court disagreed, finding express language in the state law establishing a remedy by those victimized by a breach of the Act. The Court found the school policy of discarding such private information without safeguards to be inadequate. Every school in Minnesota may now feel compelled to purchase and use shredders.
The Court might have asked why schools are collecting more and more psychological, health and other non-educational data on students. "TeenScreen" is now attempting to evaluate all schoolchildren for alleged mental disorders, despite outrage by the few parents who are aware of it. Do you remember when a student's record consisted entirely of a "report card"?