Court Monitor • Nov 29, 2006

Court Dictates Religious School Employment

Text Reader

Religious schools in the United States are older than our country itself, and have always played a vital role in advancing knowledge and culture. When the State of Oregon attempted to ban private schools, the Supreme Court famously held in favor of a constitutional right of private education. Pierce v. Society of Sisters, 268 U.S. 510 (1925). But that right means nothing if private schools must employ teachers who contradict the schools' or parents' values. If the teachers in a private school are no different from the teachers in public school, then there seems little point for a parent to pay twice for one education: first as taxpayers supporting the local public school, and then as tuition to the private school. The Seventh-Day Adventist religion, founded prior to the Civil War, operates many private hospitals and schools. This devout Christian denomination is known for its strict adherence to observing the Sabbath on Saturday rather than Sunday. The Linden Seventh-Day Adventist School is a grade school in Laurelton, New York. It employed Jewel Redhead, initially to teach third-graders and subsequently to teach fifth-graders. Her duties also included teaching Bible study once per day. Ms. Redhead, who was not married, informed her principal at the beginning of the 2001-02 school year that she was pregnant. The principal asked her if she planned to marry the father of the unborn child. She answered in the negative. A few months later the School Board of the Northeastern Conference of Seventh-Day Adventists voted to terminate the employment of Ms. Redhead, for exhibiting "immoral or unsatisfactory personal conduct inconsistent with the principles of the Seventh-day Adventist Church" under Section 3038:99 of the Atlantic Union Conference Education Code ("AUCEC"). This private school made a decision that it did not want an unwed, pregnant woman teaching fifth-graders and leading Bible study. In a free country, one would expect a religious group to be able to make such a decision. But Ms. Redhead sued, and federal District Judge Dora Irizarry ruled against the school. Redhead v. Conference of Seventh-day Adventists, 2006 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 51135 (E.D.N.Y. July 26, 2006). She said that there is a "compelling interest" in banning "discrimination," and that a jury trial would be necessary to determine whether the religious school "discriminated" against Ms. Redhead based on her being pregnant. The "ministerial exception" is a recognized exception to employment anti-discrimination laws. If the employee is performing religious duties, such as leading a religious celebration or engaging in religious instruction, then courts uphold the right of churches and synagogues to "discriminate" in order to protect their religious values. For example, under this exception the Catholic Church may restrict the hiring of priests to only men, and the employment of nuns only to women. But Judge Irizarry sharply narrowed this ministerial exception and refused to apply it to protect a religious school with respect to a teacher who taught youngsters and led Bible study. This decision subjects religious schools to many of the same restrictions on hiring and firing that apply to public schools. Linden School is now exposed to a huge jury award against it for firing Ms. Redhead. While the financial status of the Linden School is not publicly known, most religious schools cannot survive a large verdict against them. Many religious schools are already going out of business for fiscal reasons. The message to religious schools from this decision is loud and clear: don't dare fire a teacher in order to protect your values, or else face financial ruin.