A few years ago the homeschooling leadership in Pennsylvania accepted greater regulation in return for access to some state-funded activities, such as public school sports and reimbursement for online courses. In other words, some accepted the bitter (more regulation) in order to obtain the sweet (state funding of some activities).
Other homeschoolers objected at the time, and rightly so. Quickly the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania imposed the heaviest regulations on homeschoolers in the nation. Unless they use a certified teacher or private school, homeschooling parents must now comply with a dizzying array of requirements.
For starters, the parents must file a notarized affidavit with their local school district by the beginning of each year. They must maintain a daily log of actual time spent in education, including the titles of books used. The annual time must exceed 990 hours at the high school level and 900 hours at the elementary level. Favorite public school courses -- health, physiology and world history -- must be included in the homeschool curriculum.
The name, address, and telephone number of each homeschooled child must be turned over to the local school district. "An annual written evaluation of the student's educational progress as determined by a licensed clinical or school psychologist or a teacher certified by the Commonwealth or by a [qualified] nonpublic school teacher or administrator" is required. 24 Pa. Stat. Ann. § 13-1327.1(e)(2). Testing is mandatory in certain years.
At any time during the year, the local superintendent may demand documentation from a homeschooling family if he has a reasonable belief that appropriate education is not occurring (whatever that means). What is the penalty if the state determines that the homeschooling is inadequate? The child must then be "enrolled in the public school district of residence or a nonpublic school or a licensed private academic school," and the parents shall not be eligible to homeschool that child again for at least a year. 24 Pa. Stat. Ann. § 13-1327.1(j).
The Home School Legal Defense Association led a legal challenge to these laws, and a federal judge rejected every single argument. Combs v. Homer Ctr. Sch. Dist., 2005 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 32007 (W.D. Pa. Dec. 8, 2005). The Court observed that virtually every Court of Appeals has held that state regulations concerning the education of children need not survive "strict scrutiny," which is the test ordinarily applied to protect fundamental constitutional rights. In other words, the Court indicated that it will uphold any regulation of homeschoolers that merely has a rational purpose.
The Court's opinion made it appear as though public schools have a cherished tradition dating back to the founding of Pennsylvania by William Penn in 1681. The court quoted Penn's original Frame of Government: "Twelfth. That the Governors and Provincial Council shall erect and order all Public Schools, and encourage and reward authors of useful sciences and laudable inventions in the said Province." Id. at *8. But the Court overlooked how mandatory schooling has never been accepted by our nation, and how lawful parents have always had rights superior to government in raising their own children. The Court discounted the significance of several Supreme Court holdings establishing the rights of parents in raising their children, such as Pierce v. Society of Sisters, 268 U.S. 510 (1925).
In essence, the federal judiciary has told the government: Go ahead and regulate homeschooling nearly any way you like.