In many areas, the right to shoot a gun in self-defense has gone the way of the horse-and-buggy. Sometimes even the use of a gun in self-defense in one's home leads to lawsuits or criminal charges. But West Virginia remains staunchly pro-gun. When the West Virginia Supreme Court was recently confronted with a case concerning the use of a gun in self-defense, it delivered a remarkably conservative opinion.
Larry G. Dinger found himself in the middle of a dispute that had escalated to a boiling point. Dinger's 20-year-old son bloodied the nose of a drunken visitor after an argument. The visitor left and then returned with others to even the score. Larry Dinger next heard a commotion outside and discovered four people standing in his yard, anxious for a fight. Dinger grabbed a gun, stuck it in his waistband, and went outside to see what was going on. When he attempted to send his own sons inside, one man in the menacing group blocked the doorway, declaring "you are not getting [an expletive] gun."
Dinger pulled out his gun. Another man tried to grab it from Dinger, taunting him with, "if you pull a gun, you'd better use it." Dinger regained control of the gun and shot the man dead. Charged with murder, Dinger was found guilty of voluntary manslaughter, and sentenced to 15 years in jail. Dinger appealed based on the trial judge's refusal to give a self-defense instruction on his behalf.
The Supreme Court of West Virginia overturned the conviction. West Virginia v. Dinger, No. 05-32694 (Dec. 1, 2005),. It found reversible error by the trial judge in denying the defendant the argument that he was lawfully entitled to use deadly force in self-defense.
The Court held that the jury should have been given the following instruction: "When one without fault himself is attacked by another in such a manner ... as to furnish reasonable grounds for apprehending a design to take away his life, or to do him some great bodily harm, ... he may act upon such appearances and without retreating, kill his assailant, if he has reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe, that such killing is necessary in order to avoid the apparent danger." In such cases the defendant should be found not guilty.
This approved jury instruction includes the additional protection that the verdict should be "not guilty" even though "it may afterwards turn out that the appearances were false, and that there was in fact neither design to do him some serious injury nor danger, that it would be done." Note that where the defendant is without fault, he need not retreat; in this case, there was evidence that he was blocked from retreating anyway.
The trial judge had refused defendant's request that the jury be given this type of instruction. As a result of this error, the West Virginia Supreme Court overturned the conviction. Reversals of criminal convictions on appeal are exceedingly rare. It is a reflection of the strong right to bear arms in West Virginia that this defendant was able to overturn his conviction for his deadly use of a gun.