Demands for "separation of church and state" have long starved religiously affiliated institutions of funds available to everyone else. This issue came up again in a recent appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court with respect to the use of federal funds for the teaching of religion classes.
The AmeriCorps Education Awards Program funds organizations to train teachers to serve the needy. The University of Notre Dame, a religiously affiliated college, is one of the organizations that received AmeriCorps funds in order to train instructors to teach in underprivileged Catholic grade schools. These teachers instruct students in a variety of subjects including religion.
The individual teachers receive $4,725 for completing at least 1,700 hours of service in an approved position, which amounts to only $2.78 per hour. This meager amount can then be used to pay down outstanding student loans. Supporting institutions, such as Notre Dame, receive $400 for each student they train.
The AmeriCorps program funds religious and non-religious instruction alike, without discrimination. Instructors in the program who teach religion are prohibited from wearing the AmeriCorps logo during such classes. Nevertheless, Clinton-appointed trial judge Gladys Kessler ruled against the program based on the Establishment Clause.
On appeal, the Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit reversed Judge Kessler and held that the program is fully constitutional. Specifically, there is nothing wrong with government money ending up in religious instruction or even a religious institution. American Jewish Cong. v. Corp. for Nat'l and Comm'y Serv., 399 F.3d 351 (D.C. Cir. 2005). Judge A. Raymond Randolph wrote the decision for a unanimous court.
The plaintiffs seeking to invalidate the AmeriCorps payments for religious instruction relied on a 1985 Supreme Court decision, which prohibited public schools from hiring religious school instructors to teach secular classes in after-school programs in religious schools. School District of City of Grand Rapids v. Ball, 473 U.S. 373 (1985). Their argument was that if public funds cannot go towards teaching non-religious classes in religious schools, as the Supreme Court held in Ball, then public funds could not be used for teaching religious classes either.
However Judge Randolph held otherwise because the Supreme Court has overruled much of its reasoning in the Ball decision. When government itself is neutral towards religion, it is perfectly constitutional for recipients of government funds to spend the money directly on religious activities. Teachers in AmeriCorps program may use the funds to provide religious instruction, and such use is constitutional.
But what about $400 in public funds that the AmeriCorps program sends directly to a religiously affiliated school such as Notre Dame? In a rare display of common sense, the Court of Appeals held that $400 was simply too small to warrant prohibition. The $400 covers only about 8% of the salaries Notre Dame pays those training the AmeriCorps teachers.
"The government does not promote religion in violation of the Establishment Clause when it reimburses all grantees, religious and secular alike, for a portion of the costs they incur in complying with the requirements of the AmeriCorps program." 399 F.3d at 359. The D.C. Circuit then denied a petition to reconsider Judge Randolph's decision en banc. On January 9th, the Supreme Court denied cert., enabling the D.C. Circuit decision in favor of religious instructors to stand.