Court Monitor • Mar 5, 2006

A Judge Gets Around the Law

Text Reader

For nearly six years, the City of New York has waged war in federal court against gun manufacturers. Defendants include all of the prominent firearms companies, from Smith & Wesson to Colt to Browning Arms. Activist Judge Jack Weinstein of the Eastern District of New York presides over this case, and previously held court over other massive lawsuits going after big business. This time the City of New York seeks to hold the gun manufacturers liable for the firearms-related injuries, deaths, and harm to businesses in the City. According to the City's lawsuit, "In the period from August 1, 1997 through July 31, 1998, the United States Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF), through its National Firearms Tracing Database (the Trace Database), traced 8,437 guns used in crimes in New York City. The 8,437 crime guns traced were used in the commission of 433 robberies, 309 assaults/threats, 278 homicides, 143 Narcotics crimes, 101 burglaries/thefts/frauds, and 7,123 firearms-related offenses." City of New York v. Beretta U.S.A. Corp., 401 F. Supp. 2d 244, 253 (E.D.N.Y. 2005). A jury could easily award many billions of dollars annually in damages against deep-pocket manufacturers. New York City has probably already spent more than a million dollars in legal fees hoping to reach that billion-dollar payday. The theory of this case is that gun manufacturers produce and distribute guns in a manner that leads to these crimes, and that the manufacturers could take preventive measures but fail to do so. The flaw in this argument is the overwhelming body of research that shows, as John Lott phrased it in his book, More Guns, Less Crime, "Guns save far more lives than they harm." Barely a month prior to the selection of the jury in this case, President Bush signed a unique law giving gun manufacturers qualified immunity against this and similar lawsuits. Within hours of Bush's signing of the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act on October 26, 1995, defendants ran into Judge Weinstein's courtroom with a motion to dismiss the case. The Act expressly states that a lawsuit "pending on the date of enactment of this Act shall be immediately dismissed by the court in which the action was brought or is currently pending." But Judge Weinstein refused to dismiss. Although he held the Act to be constitutional, he continued the lawsuit under one of the very narrow exemptions in the Act: a gun manufacturer who knowingly violates federal or state law does not receive immunity. Judge Weinstein found an obscure New York law, Penal Law Section 240.45, which only applies when someone "knowingly or recklessly creates or maintains a condition which endangers the safety or health of a considerable number of persons." A gun manufacturer has never been prosecuted under this law and there was no judicial authority for Judge Weinstein to find that one could be, but he nevertheless linked this law to the exemption in the Act and ordered the lawsuit to continue against gun manufacturers. It is unlikely the judge would have so held had the Act included this provision: It shall be an impeachable offense for a judge to refuse to apply this Act properly to dismiss a lawsuit against gun manufacturers.