Court Monitor • Apr 15, 2006

Texas Supremacists Order School Funding

Text Reader

So many state courts have ordered their legislatures to raise taxes for public schools that it's not even news when it happens. Courts were never given the authority to raise taxes, but the urge is too irresistible for supremacist judges. The supposedly conservative Texas Supreme Court has just joined the list of activist courts who bark out commands to legislatures to fund schools. Its decision was written by Texas Supreme Court Justice Nathan Hecht, known to the public as the conservative friend of President Bush's personal pick for the U.S. Supreme Court, Harriet Miers. Presenting himself as a conservative, Justice Hecht repeatedly insisted that Miers was another conservative worthy of confirmation. But on November 22, 2005, Justice Hecht declared that the Texas legislature must both increased funding of the public schools and restructure its entire funding system. Neeley v. W. Orange-Cove Consolidated Independent School District, 176 S.W.3d 746 (Sup. Ct. Tex. 2005). "[S]tructural changes, and not merely increased funding, are needed in the public education system to meet the constitutional challenges that have been raised." Id. at 800. Justice Hecht embraced prior activist rulings of the Texas Supreme Court instead of limiting and overruling them. For example, Justice Hecht emphasized that the requirement in the Texas Constitution that public education be "efficient" somehow means that funding must be equalized across the massive state. Justice Hecht then gave the Texas legislature, which is ordinarily out of session at this time, until June 1, 2006 to completely revamp and increase its funding of public schools. Emergency sessions and political chaos have predictably followed, with new income taxes appearing likely in order to appease the Court. To reach his shocking conclusion, Justice Hecht granted unprecedented standing to school districts to sue for increased funding. "Before today, we have never held that government agencies have standing to sue the State for a bigger budget." Id. at 805 (Brister, J., dissenting). Justice Hecht even cited numerous authorities against standing for such plaintiffs, only to ignore them and demand legislattion anyway. "Normally, this Court strictly enforces standing so that we retain our proper role; hopefully today's exception is good for this case only." Id. at 808 (Brister, J., dissenting). This lawsuit was brought by school districts in wealthy areas that wanted more funding than a state-imposed cap on property taxes would allow. Their legal argument was a connivance: they cited a constitutional prohibition on statewide property taxes, and argued by implication that prohibits statewide caps also. The plaintiffs never paid a dime of property tax and had no legitimate complaint against the caps, yet Justice Hecht threw out the funding system anyway. In dissent, Justice Brister easily picked apart Justice Hecht's majority decision. "In the name of 'efficiency,' several school districts again ask the Texas courts to close the Texas public schools unless the Texas Legislature increases funding. Over the last two decades, we have been asked to do this every two or three years, and have generally complied. The Court goes too far by doing so again today." Id. at 800. Justice Hecht's supremacist opinion is a sobering reminder of how important it is to study what judges write, not what they say to appease an executive or the media, prior to nominating or confirming them.