Court Monitor • Apr 2, 2006

Maryland Court Proves ERA = Same-Sex Marriage

Text Reader

A Maryland court has followed the lead of the Massachusetts Supreme Court, holding on January 20th that "preventing same-sex marriage has no rational relationship to any ... legitimate state interest." Deane v. Conaway, Case No.: 24-C-04-005390 (Murdock, J.). The court thereby ordered the State of Maryland to issue same-sex marriage licenses, despite the fact that the Maryland legislature had prohibited such a ruling. Under its broad reasoning, the court declared that the state could never ban same-sex marriage because the judge felt there was no acceptable basis for adhering to traditional marriage. A mere stroke of his pen thereby relegated thousands of years of the history of marriage to the trash heap. Lacking authentic precedent in Maryland for its decision, the court cited the state Equal Rights Amendment (ERA). The Maryland ERA was passed in November 1972, inserting into its constitution the phrase that "equality of rights under the law shall not be abridged or denied because of sex." ERA opponents predicted that this would be used to impose same-sex marriage, but many ERA supporters stridently denied this. The ERA opponents were right. The Maryland court invoked its state ERA as primary authority for ordering same-sex marriage licenses, despite the fact that the Maryland General Assembly passed a law the following year declaring, "Only a marriage between a man and a woman is valid in this State." Family Law Article § 2-201. The plaintiffs in this lawsuit to establish same-sex marriage argued that "but for their sexual identities, they would be permitted to marry their partner under Maryland law." Even though same-sex marriage licenses are denied equally to applicants of both genders, the court nevertheless held that denial of such licenses violated the state ERA. The Maryland court declared, "It is inaccurate and overly abstract to describe §2-201 as equally prohibiting men and women from marrying members of their own sex. Section 2-201 bars a man from marrying a male partner when a woman would enjoy the right to marry that same male partner. As compared to the woman, the man is disadvantaged solely because of his sex. In the opinion of the Court, Family Law §2-201 discriminates on its face based on gender." The Maryland court thereby followed the lead of the decisive fourth Massachusetts Supreme Court Justice in its 4-3 verdict for same-sex marriage. Massachusetts v. Goodridge, 440 Mass. 309, 334, 798 N.E.2d 941, 963 (2003). That Justice also cited his state ERA as a basis for mandating same-sex marriage licensing. In defense of traditional marriage, Maryland attorneys cited the state's interest in promoting procreation and child-rearing, but the court rejected those arguments. It conceded that an Arizona court found that children "will have better opportunities to be nurtured and raised by two parents within long-term, committed relationships, which society has traditionally viewed as advantageous for children." Standhardt v. Superior Court of Arizona, 206 Ariz. 276, 288, 77 P.3d 451, 463 (2003). But the Maryland court insisted that such logic "exceeds the scope of reasonable legislative speculation." Likewise, the court flatly rejected arguments for traditional marriage based on history and uniformity with federal and other state laws.