Court Monitor • Apr 30, 2006

Chief Justice Roberts Appeases Both Sides

Text Reader

When John Roberts was nominated as Chief Justice, all conceded that he was likely to vote like Chief Justice Rehnquist, but some feared his career-long silence about many major issues could be a bad omen. In the two biggest cases of his first term, Roberts seemed to go out of his way to duck controversy and appease both sides. Ayotte v. Planned Parenthood concerned an appeal from a lower court's invalidation of New Hampshire's law requiring parental notification prior to performing abortions on underage girls. Rumsfeld v. F.A.I.R. was an appeal from a court invalidation of the Solomon Amendment, which cuts off federal funding of universities if they exclude military recruiters. In both cases, the lower court had struck down a duly enacted law, and Chief Justice Roberts probably had enough votes to issue strong opinions upholding the laws. Instead, it appears that Roberts engineered unanimous decisions of little value, diluted to please everyone, instead of principled opinions to resolve the controversies. In Ayotte, Roberts assigned the drafting of the opinion to Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, despite her imminent departure from the Court. Her decision dodged the issues and resolved nothing by remanding the case to the lower court for its reconsideration. In F.A.I.R., Roberts surely had sufficient votes to uphold congressional power to deny funding to universities that exclude military recruiters, but he wrote the opinion himself, catering to both sides of the Court. He relied on a misguided statement by the Solicitor General, at oral argument, allowing universities to organize protests against military recruiters and even post hostile signs at the entrance to the interviewing room. That unwarranted statement seems to contradict the congressional command that military recruiters have the same access as other employers, but Roberts' opinion allowed universities to single out military recruiters for protests and criticism. Roberts' approval of these tactics, without legal basis, can only be understood as appeasement of opponents of the Solomon Amendment. Even more unfortunate was that Roberts repeatedly invoked the liberal decision of Grove City College v. Bell, 465 U.S. 555 (1984), which granted the federal government power over an entirely private and independent college based merely on the receipt of education grants by a fraction of its students. This was strange because student loans were not an issue in the F.A.I.R. case. His accommodating opinion opens the door to potential federal coercion of purely private colleges that do not accept federal funding, if some of their students do. It is worrisome that when presented with two big opportunities to render principled but controversial decisions, Roberts chose instead to try to please everyone. Roberts promised at his confirmation hearing to judge like an umpire, but umpires do not try to please both sides with the same decision.