It was national news a decade ago when two public school employees in Florida tape-recorded a phone call involving then-Speaker Newt Gingrich and now-Majority Leader John Boehner, using a radio scanner to pick up the call from Boehner's cell phone as he was driving in the area. The recording caused a media sensation when published by the New York Times and Atlanta Journal-Constitution a few weeks later.
The eavesdroppers did not give the recording to the media. They delivered it to Rep. James McDermott, the ranking Democrat on the House Ethics Committee at the time. It is illegal to secretly tape record someone else's telephone call, and the eavesdroppers eventually pled guilty to a crime.
Soon after listening to the tape, McDermott shared it with two reporters: Jeanne Cummings of the Atlanta Journal-Constitution and Adam Clymer of the New York Times. Clymer then visited McDermott's office to make a copy of the tape, and Clymer ran a front-page article in the New York Times disclosing its key contents and embarrassing Gingrich.
McDermott insisted on concealing his identity, and Clymer obliged, revealing only that the tape came from a Democratic congressman. But then the original eavesdroppers, John and Alice Martin, held a news conference and said they gave the tape to McDermott. McDermott then resigned from the House Ethics Committee. Boehner subsequently sued McDermott for invading his privacy.
Though the original eavesdropping was obviously illegal, McDermott argued that he had a First Amendment right to disclose the tape because he did not participate in the eavesdropping. The Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit disagreed. Writing for the Court, Judge Raymond Randolph held in favor of Boehner in his lawsuit against McDermott for disclosing an unlawful tape recording. Boehner v. McDermott, 441 F.3d 1010 (D.C. Cir. 2006). The legal issue was this: does the federal statute that prohibits eavesdropping also prohibit disclosure by others of tape-recorded calls?
The applicable statute, 18 U.S.C. § 2511(1)(c), expressly prohibits disclosure "knowing or having reason to know that the information was obtained through the interception of a ... communication in violation of" the federal law. That seems clear enough to prohibit McDermott's conduct, but an intervening Supreme Court decision of Bartnicki v. Vopper, 532 U.S. 514 (2001) converted the test to whether McDermott "unlawfully" obtained the illegal tape recording.
The Court of Appeals held that McDermott did obtain it unlawfully. "It is the difference between someone who discovers a bag containing a diamond ring on the sidewalk and someone who accepts the same bag from a thief, knowing the ring inside to have been stolen. The former has committed no offense; the latter is guilty of receiving stolen property, even if the ring was intended only as a gift."
As a result, McDermott owes Boehner $60,000 in damages and in excess of $600,000 in legal fees. McDermott is appealing to the Supreme Court.