Longview Fibre Company of Washington State sought to fill its customer service clerk/order checker opening. While interviewing candidate Stacy Hegwine, Longview Fibre indicated that the job entailed lifting objects weighing as much as 25 pounds. Subsequent evidence showed that the job included lifting four to six boxes a day weighing between 30 and 60 pounds.
Ms. Hegwine was offered the job, pending successful completion of a physical. The physical and related questionnaire, however, indicated that she was pregnant, and her attending doctor initially approved her lifting boxes overhead weighing only 20 pounds, and lifting only 30 pounds to her waist. After her doctor placed those limitations on her ability to lift boxes, the company then declined to allow her to fill the job.
Ms. Hegwine sued, and the company prevailed in a bench trial. But the appellate court reversed and ordered judgment in favor of Ms. Hegwine for sex discrimination. Hegwine v. Longview Fibre Co., 2006 Wash. App. LEXIS 723 (2006). The appellate court even awarded attorney's fees to Ms. Hegwine for the appeal, and remanded to the trial court to determine her damage award.
Washington State's Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) played a role in this decision. "This state's strong policy against sex discrimination is further evidenced by its enactment of the Equal Rights Amendment to the state constitution. Const. art. XXXI, §§ 1-2 (amend. 61)." Id. at *17 (quoting Marquis v. Spokane, 130 Wn.2d 97, 109, 922 P.2d 43 (1996)).
Before suing, Ms. Hegwine had returned to her doctor to seek removal of his medical limitation on her ability to lift heavy boxes. Specifically, she complained about his 20 pound limitation on overhead lifting, and her doctor contacted the company to identify the precise lifting requirements. The doctor then submitted a revised medical clearance form declaring that she could lift overhead up to 40 pounds. The company, however, never allowed her to fill the job. At trial, her doctor even testified that, if he had learned the job required lifting 60 pounds, then he may have even provided medical clearance for that.
The company's Equal Employment Opportunity Coordinator testified at trial that the job required lifting boxes weighing up to 60 pounds, carrying them 15 to 30 feet and down three or four steps, loading them onto a small Daihatsu truck, driving them to another building, unloading them onto a hand truck, and pulling them to a destination. This witness also testified that the company might have been able to transfer Ms. Hegwine to another job to avoid these lifting requirements, but the applicant did not request such an accommodation.
Yet the Washington State Court of Appeals was unimpressed by these lifting requirements. It attached great significance to the company's lack of a written description of them. As to the doctor's changing limits for lifting, the Court blamed the company for being unclear about its weight requirements.
Remarkably, the Court held that the company had discriminated on the basis of sex against Ms. Hegwine, even though the company had hired her in the first place. "We do note, however, that certain biological and legal principles clearly apply in this case - only women get pregnant ...." Indeed. And based on that observation the court converted a legitimate disagreement about suitability for a job into a judgment against the company for sex discrimination.