Court Monitor • Jun 29, 2006

Key Evolution Decision Overturned

Text Reader

Last year, a Clinton-appointed federal judge in Georgia prohibited the Cobb County school board from placing a sticker on textbooks saying that evolution is not a fact but a theory that should be approached with an open mind. Selman v. Cobb County Sch. Dist., 390 F. Supp. 2d 1286 (N.D. Ga. 2005). Specifically, the judge barred use of this disclaimer: "This textbook contains material on evolution. Evolution is a theory, not a fact, regarding the origin of living things. This material should be approached with an open mind, studied carefully, and critically considered." The judge did not find an unconstitutional religious purpose behind the disclaimer, but insisted that it has the effect of advancing religion and thereby fails to comport with the Supreme Court's notorious Lemon test. Under such an extreme approach, many accepted practices could be banned; it could even be argued that not holding classes on Sunday has an effect of helping religion. Most Americans would encourage students to have a healthy skepticism about what they are taught in public school. But to some, including many in the judiciary, evolution enjoys a special status that somehow puts it above criticism in schools. This Cobb County decision in favor of evolution soon became the holy grail to its supporters. Subsequently, in a much-publicized decision against a Pennsylvania school board, Judge John E. Jones III relied heavily on the Cobb County decision. He cited it repeatedly, relying on it for the proposition that describing evolution as a theory and not a fact somehow violates the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. Calling evolution a theory "is 'one of the latest strategies to dilute evolution instruction employed by anti-evolutionists with religious motivations,'" wrote Judge Jones in Kitzmiller v. Dover Area School District, 400 F. Supp. 2d 707, 728 (M.D. Pa. 2005) (quoting the Cobb County decision). The judge was so fond of that phrase from the Cobb County decision that he copied it verbatim twice in his decision, once without quotations acknowledging the copying. But this turns out to have been without good legal foundation. The Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit found insufficient justification in the record for the Cobb County decision. Like the gaping holes in the theory of evolution itself, the trial court's decision in the Cobb County case was unsupported by its own evidentiary record. On appeal, the Eleventh Circuit ruled that "the unfilled gaps in the record, coupled with the problematic nature of some of the district court's factfindings, prevent proper appellate review of the merits of the important constitutional issues raised in this case." Selman v. Cobb County Sch. Dist., 2006 U.S. App. LEXIS 13005, *2 (11th Cir. May 25, 2006). The Eleventh Circuit paid no heed to the Dover Area School District decision, which likewise invalidated a "theory ... not a fact" disclaimer to be read to students, but remanded the case for further proceedings. This legal charade may not continue much longer, now that there are five Justices on the U.S. Supreme Court who we hope will curtail the judiciary's hostility to religion, which began with the activist Warren Court. With two new Justices making the Supreme Court more open-minded on this issue, it is only a matter of time before evolution loses its position as the sacred cow that school boards may not criticize. As many as five states now allow open criticism of evolution, and it seems unlikely that the new Supreme Court will impose a constitutional ban on critical thinking.