The Ninth Circuit has upheld a ban on social workers having a religious conversation with the unemployed. Berry v. Dep't of Soc. Servs., 2006 U.S. App. LEXIS 10796 (9th Cir. May 1, 2006). The Court rejected a claim by an evangelical Christian that this censorship violated his First Amendment rights to free speech and free exercise of religion and his rights under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act.
On Dec. 6, 2001, the Department of Social Services in Tehama County, California, sent employee Daniel M. Berry a letter of reprimand. In the letter, the Department stated that Berry was prohibited from displaying religious items in his cubicle in a manner visible to "clients," the term used to describe unemployed or underemployed recipients of government services. The letter ordered Berry to remove the name "Jesus" from his sign and to conceal his Bible from the view of clients. Berry complied.
The letter of reprimand stated, "You may put the Bible in your desk or in a large envelope which we are providing you. You are instructed to remove the 'Jesus' part of your Happy Birthday Jesus sign which you have placed on the wall of your work area. The issue is that the Bible and other religious non-verbal communications can not be visible to your clients."
Berry then complained to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, which responded by granting him the right to sue. Berry sued and lost in district court, and then lost again on appeal to the Ninth Circuit.
No client had ever complained about Berry's faith. But when Mr. Berry pointed that out to the Ninth Circuit, it declared that argument to be "not well taken." Why not? The Court did not explain.
But this turns out to have been without good legal foundation. The Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit found insufficient justification in the record for the Cobb County decision. Like the gaping holes in the theory of evolution itself, the trial court's decision in the Cobb County case was unsupported by its own evidentiary record. On appeal, the Eleventh Circuit ruled that "the unfilled gaps in the record, coupled with the problematic nature of some of the district court's factfindings, prevent proper appellate review of the merits of the important constitutional issues raised in this case." Selman v. Cobb County Sch. Dist., 2006 U.S. App. LEXIS 13005, *2 (11th Cir. May 25, 2006).
Instead, the Court expressed its disapproval of the following conduct by Berry: "In deposition testimony, Plaintiff has admitted that from time to time he has had religious conversations with, or prayed in the presence of County's clients. On one occasion, he prayed in the presence of one of his Hispanic clients who first asked him to pray for a family member, and later asked Plaintiff to pray directly with her, which he did. On another occasion, Plaintiff prayed in Spanish for a client who was caught being dishonest, however, he did not believe that the client knew that Plaintiff was praying for him at the time."
The Ninth Circuit upheld the ban on Berry's speech, saying it was justified by application of the Establishment Clause against religion in government. Berry only engaged in this speech when he felt it was appropriate, but that made no difference to the Court. The Court also rejected Berry's free exercise and civil rights claims.
This decision sets the stage for the newly composed Supreme Court to overrule some of its most intolerant decisions under the Establishment Clause.