Court Monitor • Jul 27, 2006

"Choose Life" License Plates

Text Reader

The Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit upheld "Choose Life" license plates against the complaints of the ACLU and a dissenting judge appointed by President Carter. ACLU of Tennessee v. Bredesen, 2006 U.S. App. LEXIS 6603 (Mar. 17, 2006). Like many southern states, Tennessee had enacted a law enabling citizens to buy a specialty license plate for an extra charge in order to display the words "Choose Life." There is nothing controversial about specialty license plates, which are common nationwide. What sparked emotions was the use of a pro-life message rather than the blander slogans already available. The ACLU sued and persuaded the District court to invalidate Tennessee's law allowing "Choose Life" plates. The ACLU argued that a pro-life message should not be allowed because Tennessee did not allow a message favored by abortion-rights advocates on license plates. The Sixth Circuit, which presides over Michigan, Ohio, Kentucky and Tennessee, has long been a battleground between conservative and liberal judges. It is evenly split on ideological grounds, as six of the active judges were appointed by Presidents Clinton and Carter, while eight were appointed by Presidents Reagan and the two Bushes. On issues concerning abortion and religion, some of the judges appointed by Republican presidents usually switch sides. Democratic Senators blocked the confirmation of one presumably pro-life Bush nominee (Henry Saad) for that court for nearly five years, and he recently withdrew his name. By the luck of the draw, the Sixth Circuit assigned this case to a panel of two Republican-appointed judges and one Democratic-appointed judge, and the vote came out 2-1 in favor of the "Choose Life" plates. The scholarly decision written by Judge John H. Rogers explained how a long line of Supreme Court precedents support government-sponsored speech on a variety of topics. For example, the Supreme Court implicitly upheld the power of New Hampshire to issue "Live Free or Die" license plates, although it could not compel a driver to display that motto against his will. Wooley v. Maynard, 430 U.S. 705 (1977). "The evil in Wooley was that the automobile owners were compelled to disseminate the message; here automobile owners are not only not compelled, they have to pay extra to disseminate the message," Judge Rogers wrote. Then Judge Rogers disposed of the argument that if Tennessee allows a "Choose Life" license plate, it must also allow a license plate motto favored by abortion-rights advocates. Judge Rogers observed that such reasoning would require Tennessee to allow license plates advertising the "Ku Klux Klan or the American Nazi Party. Plaintiffs' position implies that Tennessee must provide specialty plates for these hate groups in order for it constitutionally to provide specialty plates supporting any institution. Such an argument falls of its own weight." Judge Martin in dissent made a thinly veiled plea for the Supreme Court to resolve this issue, noting that "at least three circuits (4th, 5th, and 6th) … have spoken on the issue, reaching at least three different conclusions, via at least sixteen separate opinions." The Fourth Circuit, including Supreme Court candidate Judge Luttig, ruled against "Choose Life" plates. The Fifth Circuit, led by the remarkable Judge Edith Jones, held that federal courts lack jurisdiction to review the revenue-producing issue of state license plates, thereby allowing Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi to offer "Choose Life" plates. The stage is now set for the new Roberts-Alito Supreme Court to address this divisive issue.