Last year's 5-4 decision by the U.S. Supreme Court in Kelo v. City of New London allowed the taking of property from one private party (a homeowner) to give to another (a developer). The motivation for such "taking" by local governments is to boost their tax revenue, often to meet shortfalls in their own budgets. But the Kelo decision set off a firestorm of protests, with the aftershocks still being felt today.
28 state legislatures reacted to the ruling by passing laws providing some protection against abusive takings of private property for another private purpose, such as a development. However, some of those bills are more for show to appease an angry public, and confer little actual protection.
But on July 26, the Ohio Supreme Court stunned observers with a unanimous decision against a $125 million development project in a Cincinnati suburb in City of Norwood v. Horney. The Institute for Justice, which had narrowly lost the Kelo case, won vindication here on behalf of homeowners.
This case starkly illustrates how abusive eminent domains are motivated by local governments seeking new sources of revenue for their own budgets. The City of Norwood hoped to receive $2 million annually in new tax revenue from a new development based on this taking. The developer had already bulldozed every house except three on the site. Joy Gamble was a holdout who had lived in her house for 35 years, raised her children there, and hoped to remain there for her retirement.
When the mayor of Norwood heard that the homeowners had won, he was despondent: The city is running one h--- of a deficit." He predicted that, without the new development and its expected tax revenue, the city would run out of money by October. It might actually have to lay off a government worker!
One might ask why Joy Gamble should lose her house simply because the city government refuses to cut its spending. Eminent domain should not be result of a city unwilling to trim government jobs and payrolls. Often developments fail to generate the promised revenue anyway, and takings should not be approved based on a combination of political desperation and rosy predictions.
Quoting an antebellum decision, the Ohio Supreme Court declared, "Believed to be derived fundamentally from a higher authority and natural law, property rights were so sacred that they could not be entrusted lightly to 'the uncertain virtue of those who govern.'" The Court reaffirmed that "Ohio has always considered the right of property to be a fundamental right," and the Court cited the English philosopher John Locke in its reasoning.
The Ohio Supreme Court then thoroughly rejected the majority view of the U.S. Supreme Court in Kelo, and instead cited favorably the dissenting opinion in that case. In so doing, Ohio joined Michigan in standing up for private property rights. The Michigan Supreme Court held in favor of private property owners and against abusive takings in County of Wayne v. Hathcock, 471 Mich. 445 (2004).
The Ohio Supreme Court concluded that "economic benefits alone," such as increased taxes, do not justify a taking of private property. The Court left open the possibility of using eminent domain to redevelop truly blighted areas, but made clear that "when the state takes an individual's private property for transfer to another individual or to [a] private entity rather than for use by the state itself, the judicial review of the taking is paramount."
Perhaps one day the U.S. Supreme Court will correct its mistake in Kelo and recognize, as the Ohio Supreme Court just did, that a "primordial purpose of the public-use" limitation on eminent domain "is to prevent the legislature from permitting the state to take private property from one individual simply to give it to another."